The climate crisis, the preservation of biodiversity, the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions... The challenges linked to sustainable development are at the heart of the concerns of citizens, governments, but also companies, which are called upon to review their operating models and their strategies in favour of a greener and more resilient economy.
In this rapidly changing world, the banking sector, which directly or indirectly finances a major part of the EU’s economy, has been called upon to play a central role in accompanying and supporting this necessary transition. “This commitment has several dimensions,” said Arnaud Jacquemin, CEO of Société Générale Luxembourg. “To begin with, we are concerned with being a responsible banker, strongly committed to sustainable development, and in particular to all initiatives aimed at protecting the environment, limiting global warming and preserving biodiversity.”
“This of course requires us to measure our own impact as a company. But, more fundamentally, our objective is to have a positive impact within the framework of our activities as a bank: on the one hand, through active participation in the financing of the economy, by accompanying companies in their own energy transition, and more broadly in their consideration of all CSR issues, and, on the other hand, within the framework of our private banking activities in particular, through sustainable investment offers for our clients, to enable them to support this transition,” Jacquemin said.
Of course, we cannot achieve our commitment to make our business carbon neutral by 2050 alone
Today, Europe is positioning itself as the world’s leading area on the subject of sustainable investment. This dynamic is reflected in the construction of a very strong legislative and regulatory environment, accompanied by new standards, in particular to enable banks to classify their investment products according to their sustainable or non-sustainable nature. The framework for sustainable finance is increasingly well defined thanks to texts such as the Sustainable Finance Directive Regulation (SFDR) and the taxonomy. Through these directives, the regulator aims for transparency and encourages companies to communicate on the environmental and social impact of their products and activities. This presents many challenges.
Necessary and fragmented information
To best assess the impact of a given company, banks need access to reliable and regularly updated information. “Obtaining quality data is a major challenge for the entire industry,” said Daniel Biever, head of investment desk at Raiffeisen. “We work in an environment that is constantly changing, especially from a regulatory point of view, so it is not always easy to manage the reliability of the data we need. On the other hand, we are confronted with a mass of heterogeneous information that we have to be able to sort out. For example, opinions on the sustainability of a fund can vary from one provider to another.”
In addition, there are complex regulations which, although they have the same purpose, sometimes use different criteria to assess whether an investment is sustainable or not. “Unlike financial data, ESG data is not yet standardised and is therefore more difficult to obtain and use," said Benn Wurth, head of risk management at Spuerkeess. “The rapid growth of the data market creates a number of limitations, which providers need to address in order to improve practices, especially in terms of transparency of methods. In addition, for a large proportion of Luxembourg companies, international data providers do not have ESG data. We therefore have to collect this new information ourselves from clients.”
Verifying the credibility of commitments
The need for accurate and verifiable information should enable banks to offer all the necessary transparency to their clients. “We obviously cannot achieve our commitment alone, which is to make our activities carbon neutral by 2050,” said Jacquemin. “This can only be done in close collaboration with the clients we finance, who themselves must assess their own impact. We therefore collectively need access to the most complete and reliable information possible, including from independent rating agencies, in order to properly calibrate the models that will make it possible to measure the precise path to be taken to fulfil the commitments made.”
These issues require specific skills, hence the importance of working with the scientific community
Even before access to information, one of the first challenges facing the sector is to agree on the definition of sustainable investment. “Environmental, social and governance issues pose new and complex challenges that were previously outside the remit of financial institutions,” said Marco Rasqué Da Silva, secretary general and vice president at the state savings bank Spuerkeess. “These issues require specific skills, which is why it is important to work with the scientific community to improve climate and environmental practices. To address this issue, we have created a Sustainability Advisory Council. This innovative project has received the official support of the Minister of Finance as well as the Spuerkeess board of directors and management. It not only brings significant value to Spuerkeess’ projects and activities, but also enriches the Luxembourg financial sector as a whole, as well as other sectors exposed to environmental risks.”
Read also
Complex subject
At the centre of this new ESG investment galaxy is the client, who is sometimes at a loss when faced with the multitude of information circulating on the subject. “The real challenge is to build an understandable and transparent offer, so that our clients can make the right decisions,” said Jacques Hoffmann, head of ESG at Raiffeisen. “We have to be able to put simple words to complex matters. Regardless of the regulations in force, the aim must be to serve the client as well as possible, to offer products that correspond to his or her expectations, from the sustainable credit card--which allows trees to be planted--to loans to finance ecological projects, via a range of investment products that a cooperative bank can offer, which is responsible and sustainable in essence.”
The creation of this sustainable offer is accompanied by a major need for education, aimed at the public, but also at the bank’s employees. “We want to avoid having CSR specialists working in isolation,” explained the CEO of Société Générale Luxembourg. “Of course, experts are needed, as the subject is complex and evolving, but our desire is to train all the teams in order to natively integrate the ESG dimension into our activities, whether it be in the way we structure financing or investment products, but also in the way we operate on a daily basis as a responsible company.” This need for training, in order to provide the client with the right information, was shared by all the sources interviewed for this article.
Starting a life-saving process
One of the major difficulties today is to act in the very short term to have a real impact on the environment and the climate. “We are still at the beginning of the road. Standards and regulations are beginning to be more coherent and organised, but the current torrent of information sometimes makes certain basic messages inaudible,” said Rasqué Da Silva. “These developments mean that we need to adapt our IT systems to deal with all these parameters and to have visibility on the paths to follow, as there is no single answer to ESG challenges.” With growing expectations from Europe and regulators, it is important for banks to get to grips with the subject matter in order to implement them in the best possible way.
The challenge remains to explain in a simple way the whole topic of sustainable investment, which covers a multitude of dimensions. But I compare it to the rise of compliance
“The difficulty is that these different regulations are all recent and are not always aligned,” said Jacquemin. “Putting them to music poses a number of substantive and technical difficulties. But in spirit, these rules make a lot of sense and should gradually enable the entire financial industry to follow a common path. The taxonomy, for example, is the first brick in an ensemble, which gives us a common dictionary; we know that it is not yet complete since, for example, it currently only deals with the environmental aspect and the social dimension is still to come. In general, not everything is written yet. It is therefore important to maintain a constructive dialogue with all the stakeholders in order to bring interpretations and practices into line.”
Also, since August 2022, banks have been obliged to ask their clients whether they want their investments to be sustainable and, if so, for what proportion of their investment portfolio. “In practice, we have drawn up a Mifid questionnaire to define our clients’ sustainability preferences”, stated Biever.
Read also
According to Jacquemin: “Today, the challenge remains to explain in a simple way the whole theme of sustainable investment, which covers a multitude of dimensions. But I compare it to the boom in compliance that we experienced a few years ago. At the beginning, it was restrictive and difficult to put in place, it represented significant costs, but today, it has become the standard.” On this subject, the banks are still waiting for the regulator’s technical details, but this should not prevent them from moving forward. “In terms of environmental transition, the work is huge. That said, we must not wait to have perfect knowledge, exhaustiveness and absolute reliability of data and modelling. On the contrary, we need to get the ball rolling, even partially. When we see the urgency of the climate and biodiversity, we must move forward in a proactive manner, even if it means refining the levers gradually.”
Climate risk to be integrated
Finally, another challenge is to take climate risks into account in a sustainable way. “This is a central topic that is actively followed by the European Central Bank,” Wurth pointed out. “In recent years, climate risk has been integrated into the bank’s risk management framework. In a first phase, Spuerkeess has set up indicators to measure climate risk by distinguishing between transition risk, e.g. in relation to financed emissions, and physical risk, such as financing a building in a flood zone. In the second quarter of 2022, we participated in the ECB’s climate stress test. It would be an aberration for each bank to develop its own model, so we have regular discussions with the ABBL [bankers trade group] and other players in the marketplace.”
Climate change and the degradation of biodiversity are processes that have impacts on the main categories of risk that a bank manages: credit risk, market risk, operational risk, etc
Taking this climate or environmental risk into account will redefine the relationship with clients. “In our view, climate or biodiversity risks are not new risk categories that should be treated separately,” stated Jacquemin. “Climate change and the degradation of biodiversity are processes that have an impact on the major categories of risk that a bank manages: credit risk, market risk, operational risk, etc… From now on, we must integrate this dimension natively into the overall analysis of a client we are financing, for example. This requires us to develop the skills of our employees who assess these risks, but also our risk management framework. This risk assessment will be refined over time with the increasing availability of reliable information and the emergence of standards set by our supervisors. But here again, it is essential to tackle the subject head on. It is central. Making trajectories more reliable will take time, but that’s no reason not to start now.”
Read the original French version of this article on the Paperjam site





