“So much false information is circulating in the public debate. Some are trying to divide us.” Nearly a month after the “serious but necessary” decision to terminate the agreements linking it to the Caisse nationale de santé (CNS), the Association des médecins et médecins-dentistes (AMMD) is more keen than ever to have its say. As well as “clearly explaining this decision”, as it did on Thursday 27 November at a press conference.
“The act of denouncing the agreements is not a deconvention,” reassures AMDD president Chris Roller from the outset. “No patient will see their rights reduced or their access to care compromised. This decision “aims to renegotiate more balanced and equitable agreements, and to correct a legal framework that has become oppressive for our professions”, says the AMMD, for whom "waiting times have become unacceptable". In this context, "terminating the agreements is an act of responsibility designed to rebalance the healthcare system as a whole".
For the association, this will make it "possible to renegotiate very important aspects such as the funding of out-of-hospital medical and dental care or digitisation, which is not operational at this stage".
This decision, taken by a large majority at the general meeting, is moreover "far from being a taboo", the AMMD further explains, pointing out that the CNS had already acted in this way in the past, in 2010.
Martine Deprez in the crosshairs
For the association, the Luxembourg healthcare system is "at the end of its tether". And "every attempt at improvement […] has come up against institutional, political and ideological resistance", it regrets. "Very recently, statements by the Minister [of Health and Social Security Martine Deprez, editor's note] suggested that our demand for autonomy would mean introducing 'two-tier medicine' and a system without subsidies. This is false."
On the contrary, the AMMD says it is fighting to put an end to the habit developed, particularly by the most well-off, of going abroad for treatment in order to "benefit from modern medical procedures not available in Luxembourg. Paradoxically, these services […] are then partially covered by the CNS, even though they could be carried out in our country if the regulatory framework were adapted to the ongoing development of medicine."
Outdated nomenclature
Another grievance: "The current negotiation model clearly works to the advantage of the CNS." "The nomenclature, which has been frozen for years, no longer reflects the evolution of medical progress. As a result, this progress is paradoxically financed by the doctors themselves: each new procedure or technology is treated as an old service, leading to a systematic undervaluation of medical work," details the AMMD.
"Although the CNS has admitted the imbalance in the system, it has so far refused to discuss it seriously," supports the association.
The CNS dressed for winter
Doctors and dentists are calling for an overhaul of the CNS's governance, considering that its Board of Directors (BD) "has shown a lack of respect on several occasions. Conflicts of interest and internal manoeuvring can no longer be ignored". The AMMD is calling for "the inclusion of direct and official representatives of policyholders" on the BD.
Automatic and compulsory copayments are also criticised. Because of it, "many practitioners, particularly dentists, set up temporarily in Luxembourg before moving abroad, while some established practitioners struggle to maintain an economically viable activity". In response, the association "will be proposing that […] accreditation should become a genuine quality criterion, based on competence, ethics and continuity of care". In the event of abuse or non-compliance, it would be suspended or withdrawn. "Such an approach would restore the value of conventionnement as a pledge of trust between patients, providers and healthcare institutions," the professionals believe.
The primary care premium
For better access to primary care, The AMMD is campaigning for "a reform of the 'group practice' project so that it is accessible to all healthcare professionals and easy to implement on the ground". In her view, this would be one way of combating the increase in the number of hospital admissions, for example: "A legal framework guaranteeing adequate funding for primary care must be discussed and obtained." The association sees itself as the poor relation when it comes to funding, in comparison with hospital medicine, with which it nevertheless declares its "solidarity". Even if it has little taste for certain statements made by the Luxembourg Hospital Federation (FHL), which it accuses of defending its sole preserve.
The suspicion of closed doors
Based on proposals made by her and the Medical College in 2022, the bill on medical societies was withdrawn "at the start of the mandate" of Minister Martine Deprez (CSV). "This bill would have led to better integration between inpatient and outpatient medicine, better pooling of resources and modernisation of collective practice,” stresses the association, which takes issue with the minister's commitment to present a new bill in the coming months. "We need to discuss its content first! It is not normal for the principles of a law called upon to govern a profession to be prepared behind closed doors!"
This stance is a bit of a charge, coming the day after the second meeting of the strategy committee responsible for getting the maternity health insurance scheme out of the financial rut, chaired by the minister herself. The committee will meet once a month, while thematic groups will be convened on a weekly basis. Its initial conclusions will be presented at the next quadripartite meeting, in spring 2026. In the meantime, Chris Roller regrets the "inertia" of healthcare policy "for the past two years".


![“In their care journey, [patients] want to share their opinion and their feelings. They then become partners. This is the basis for thinking about more modern care,” says Sylvain Vitali, Secretary General of the Fédération des hôpitaux luxembourgeois (FHL). (Photo: Julian Pierrot/Paperjam)](https://assets.paperjam.lu/images/articles/the-patient-experience-the-new-driving-force-behind-healthcare-systems/0.5/0.5/624/416/755187.jpg)
