At recruitment time, organisations no longer set their sights on candidates, but on "talent". A semantic ploy that is as flattering as it is hypocritical.  (Photo: Shutterstock)

At recruitment time, organisations no longer set their sights on candidates, but on "talent". A semantic ploy that is as flattering as it is hypocritical.  (Photo: Shutterstock)

As we make our end-of-year resolutions, let's hope that one of them will soon become part of the language of management: to do away with the systematic use of the word 'talent', as the term has lost so much of its substance by dint of referring to us all, but in truth no longer saying anything.

It's everywhere, all the time. In HR incantations, press releases, government attractiveness strategies, internal retention plans, PowerPoint presentations, Linkedin posts calibrated to the emoji, as well as in the articles I produce all week long - just yesterday, for example... In the space of a few years, the word 'talent' has infested the world of work like an epidemic, without us taking the time to ask ourselves yet what it really means.

In Luxembourg, even more than elsewhere, the term has become a reflex. Talent shortage. Talent wars. Talent attraction. Talent retention. By dint of describing everything as "talent", we no longer describe anything at all. The experienced developer, the promising young graduate, the seasoned cashier, the worn-out manager, the lawyer in search of meaning or the untraceable technician are transformed, by a lazy semantic shift, into "talents". A flabby category. A lexical catch-all into which professional realities that are nonetheless all different are thrown indiscriminately.

Not everyone is Zidane

Following the example of philosopher Julia de Funès, many critics are raising their voices against the inflationary use of this term in companies. On the side of HR practitioners, the diagnosis can even sometimes be head-on. In an interview with Paperjam, Dominique Herickx, founder of Testa-RH Consulting, explained it in his own colourful way as long ago as last year: "Let's take the example of this expression 'talent war'," challenged the man who also decries the categorisation of employees according to their age bracket. "I'm sorry, but I don't see anyone with a machine gun or tanks fighting on a battlefield! I don't like that expression. A study asked business people, including HR people, to define talent. No one was able to do it... It's proof that we use concepts out of the box, without questioning them." It could hardly be clearer.

And yet, the word talent has not disappeared from our dictionaries. On the contrary, when it is used sparingly and advisedly, it continues to have a strong connotation. Zidane has talent. Of course he does. Because he accomplished on the pitch what no-one else could do, under pressure, under the eyes of the whole world. Dvořák is talented. Because a few bars are enough to recognise a singular musical voice, to bend the stomach. David Hockney has talent. Because his gaze turns banality into majesty. That's where the word comes in. It refers to the exceptional. The rare. The inaccessible.

Lies of omission

In business, he tells no such story. Today, the notion of "talent" is used mainly to avoid saying anything else. The skills that are really lacking. Perfectible working conditions. Salaries that are sometimes out of touch. Property pressures. Transport saturation. It's a smooth word. Reassuring. Flattering. Pats itself on the back. As if the issue wasn't so much understanding why some people leave - or don't come - as brandishing a word of refuge that serves to sweep under the carpet some of what we don't want to see.

Talent war? No, work is not a hunt. Nor are employees game. Nor are they potential Ballon d'Or winners, unfinished symphonies or artists to be revealed by a bright open space or a table football table available to employees. By dint of glorifying 'talent', we also end up making the effort invisible. Progress. Learning. Loyalty. Ordinary, conscientious professionalism. The kind that doesn't shine brightly, but keeps organisations on their feet, morning after morning.

Bref, the word "talent" promises much, but delivers little. It suggests recognition, but more often than not produces frustration. It designates the exception, but becomes the norm. It claims meaning, but rarely transcends the loose boundaries of an oh-so-hollow and hypocritical slogan.

By dint of being used so much, everywhere, all the time, some words end up getting tired. So in 2026, I'm going to give 'talent' a rest. And if I fail, the proof will be in the pudding, unsurprisingly, that I certainly lack it.