The move to unlimited teleworking in return for tax compensation raises many questions, both on the French and Luxembourg sides. (Photo: Shutterstock)

The move to unlimited teleworking in return for tax compensation raises many questions, both on the French and Luxembourg sides. (Photo: Shutterstock)

France is considering allowing its border workers to telework without restriction in exchange for tax compensation from Luxembourg, according to Lorraine representatives of the Nupes party following discussions with the economy ministry.

French border workers can currently telework 29 days a year without being taxed in their country of residence. This quota is to be increased to 34 days, after validation on the French side.

The subject was discussed at a meeting on Tuesday 30 August between Luxembourg prime minister Xavier BettelXavier Bettel (DP) and French prime minister Elisabeth Borne.

According to a press release from three Lorraine elected representatives, France would study concrete solutions to go further. "On Friday 2 September 2022, the office of the economy ministry brought together members of parliament from Lorraine to present their proposals to the Luxembourg government with a view to tax negotiations between the two countries on teleworking," stated MPs Martine Etienne and Charlotte Leduc and senator Olivier Jacquin. "The government has announced that it wishes to increase the use of telework by simplifying the procedures for Luxembourg companies through the introduction of an advance payment deducted directly by the Directorate General of Public Finances. Bruno Le Maire's advisors would then have spoken of "unlimited telework within the framework of intergovernmental tax compensation".

The risks of relocation

This announcement raises many questions. In a parliamentary question, CSV MPs Marc Spautz Marc Spautz and Gilles RothGilles Roth asked for the Luxembourg government's position on the proposals, and for clarification on the compensation system cited and the method of deducting the advance payment. "This begs the question whether the agreement in principle of October 2021 allowing French border workers to benefit from 34 days of teleworking is now null and void.”

Added to this is the problem of social security, since even if the tax limits are abolished, a European regulation requires workers who carry out more than 25% of their activity (generally about 60 days) from home to join the social security system of their country of residence.

The news is accompanied by fears on the part of the Lorraine representatives, who describe it as "another tax gift" to the grand duchy. "These agreements do not take into account the issue of French companies that could relocate to Luxembourg and the increased risk of creating a harmful differential between the two countries," they said. “Furthermore, will the money that France would receive from Luxembourg be dedicated to the local authorities that provide training and finance public services essential to the lives of border workers?”

This is a subject under discussion which seems to be a long way from becoming a reality.

When contacted, the Luxembourg finance ministry stated that more information will be available in the parliamentary response on this subject. The French economy ministry did not respond to Delano's sister publication Paperjam's requests.

This story was first published in French on Paperjam. It has been translated and edited for Delano.