The European court found that at the date of the European Commission's decision, the United States provided a level of protection for personal data "substantially equivalent" to that guaranteed by the EU. Photo: Shutterstock

The European court found that at the date of the European Commission's decision, the United States provided a level of protection for personal data "substantially equivalent" to that guaranteed by the EU. Photo: Shutterstock

This is a crucial decision for the global digital economy. The General Court of the European Union on Wednesday validated the new framework for the transfer of personal data between the European Union and the United States, rejecting an appeal that had called for it to be annulled.

Filed by Philippe Latombe, a French MEP and data protection advocate, this appeal challenged the adequacy decision adopted by the European Commission in July 2023. The aim of this decision was to re-establish a legal mechanism allowing European companies to transfer data to the United States, following the invalidation of previous frameworks by the Court of Justice of the EU in the famous Schrems I (2015) and Schrems II (2020) rulings.

To convince Brussels, the United States had put in place a series of reforms, notably via Presidential Executive Order 14086, signed in October 2022, and a regulation by the US Attorney General. These texts strengthen the guarantees surrounding the activities of US intelligence agencies and introduce a new independent appeal mechanism: the Data Protection Review Court (DPRC).

But for Philippe Latombe, these guarantees remain insufficient. In particular, he felt that the DPRC was neither impartial nor independent, and that the mass surveillance carried out by the US intelligence services was not sufficiently strictly regulated.

The Court was not convinced. It considers that the appointment and operation of the DPRC judges are accompanied by sufficient safeguards to guarantee their independence. It also notes that intelligence activities are subject to a posteriori control - something that previous judgments had not required in the form of prior authorisation.

By validating the new transatlantic framework, the Court confirms that, at the date of the Commission's decision, the United States provided a level of protection of personal data "substantially equivalent" to that guaranteed by the Union.

This ruling provides legal certainty for data transfers between the two blocs, a major issue for thousands of businesses, particularly in the cloud, online commerce, social networking and digital advertising sectors. However, the European Commission is still obliged to monitor developments in the US framework. If the safeguards are weakened, it could suspend or amend its adequacy decision.

An appeal can still be lodged with the Court of Justice of the European Union, within two months and ten days. But for the time being, the Data Privacy Framework, the official name of the new mechanism, is holding firm. It remains to be seen whether it will survive future legal trials... or a possible Schrems III.

This article was originally published in French.