Officially presented on 4 June, Smartspires aims to make Belval “a full-scale testing ground for the urban technologies of the future” and “a living laboratory for the smart city, on a European scale.” The public-private consortium (made of the Luxembourg Institute of Science and Technology (List), who contributed €565,000; Orange, who contributed €1m; Gcore, who contributed €773,000; and the Dutch company 5Skye, responsible for €755,000) promises to demonstrate how “digital infrastructure combined with artificial intelligence can make urban services safer, more sustainable and more efficient.” The inevitably positive tone of the press kit contrasts with the fact that it took ten years for the first national discussions on the intelligent city to materialise. For the time being, the concrete scope of Smartspires remains confined to Belval--a long way from its stated ambitions.
In reality, Luxembourg has been examining the concept of the intelligent city since the early 2010s. The government has made the “intelligent city” one of its priorities, and the List points out that it has been investing “for more than a decade” in digital technologies dedicated to cities. The grand duchy already has “a well-established digital infrastructure fabric” in sectors such as mobility, energy and water management. These assets provide the foundations for innovation, but the implementation of concrete projects has long lacked scale. Initial experiments in smart mobility, urban sensors or open data platforms have been timid compared with what many neighbouring capitals are deploying.
Technically, Smartspires is banking on 5G and edge AI to offer advanced urban services with very low latency. According to the press release, the project relies “on the synergy between densified 5G connectivity and state-of-the-art computing infrastructure to enable AI and IOT-based services in very low latency environments.” In practice, Belval will see the deployment of at least three “intelligent towers,” each equipped with 5G antennas, computing capacity for local AI (edge computing) and IOT sensors dedicated to innovative use cases (mobility, crowd analysis, waste management, etc.). This infrastructure “will form the backbone of real-time, data-intensive applications that will improve urban management and services, providing a scalable model for European cities looking to integrate advanced 5G, edge computing and IOT solutions.” In other words, Smartspires promises a technological showcase: using 5G towers to test uses of the future.
Limited scope but scalable project
But this prototype remains confined to a very limited area. Smartspires is a university living lab, managed by the List, which will serve as an experimental platform for new urban solutions based on 5G. The day-to-day reality will remain unchanged outside the campus: this is not a deployment on the scale of the grand duchy. Several interested municipalities--such as Bettembourg or Dudelange--are taking part in the study, but we’re still a long way from a “densified” connection for the entire country. Setting up a high-speed 5G network that is “secure and sustainable” (as the project claims) is expensive and raises questions about radio spectrum governance and data confidentiality. Smartspires aims to be “scalable, secure and sustainable” in the long term, but for the moment its scope is limited to Belval.
From the point of view of governance and citizen participation, Smartspires is not yet revolutionising practices. The four planned use cases are designed in consultation with local players (such as the Fonds Belval and the Esch Forum) and should involve “a wide range of stakeholders, including the general public, startups and researchers.” The project is intended to be “a replicable model for other European cities,” whilst creating tangible benefits for Belval and its communities. In practice, the scheme is still being piloted by the state (via the List) as part of public-private partnerships.
Many advances... elsewhere
The question remains whether this approach is inclusive: unlike Barcelona, which has banked on “e-democracy” (with its Decidim platform) and claims to be a leader in e-democracy and intelligent technology, transforming its economy and promoting the active participation of citizens, Luxembourg has not yet established a genuine space for citizen consultation on these urban projects.
When compared, several European capitals have already taken much more ambitious steps. Zurich, ranked Europe’s leading intelligent city by IMD ahead of Oslo, Geneva, Dubai and Abu Dhabi (Luxembourg is 31st), for example, is multiplying experiments with augmented reality and digital twins to plan urban development, increase citizen participation and strengthen public safety.
Barcelona has long served as a benchmark: it has deployed an extensive network of sensors (parking management, smart bins, adaptive LED lighting, etc.) and relied on open data and participation tools to reinvigorate its local governance. The work of Francesca Bria, Barcelona’s “e-democracy” strategy asserts that “cities and their citizens should be the true owners of the data generated in the urban environment, in order to improve public services and advance their policies.”
Finally, Oslo is betting on urban sustainability: the Norwegian capital has set itself the target of reducing its emissions by 95% by 2030 (and aims to become carbon neutral by 2050). It is investing heavily in zero-emission buses and taxis, intelligent street lighting and open data platforms for environmental and traffic monitoring.
Even if Smartspires appears modest, the minister delegate to the prime minister for media and connectivity Elisabeth Margue (CSV) sees it as “an important step in Luxembourg’s digital transformation” and stresses that whilst the project “consists of testing technologies, its real aim is to improve citizens’ lives, enhance sustainability and shape the evolution of European cities towards greater intelligence and responsiveness.”
The fact remains that for the grand duchy, moving from Belval to Luxembourg City, then to all the country’s communes, is a considerable leap. Rolling out these 5G/edge infrastructures throughout the country still poses a number of challenges (costs, multi-level governance, resilience, data security, public acceptability). If “Smartspires transforms Belval into a connected laboratory for the city of tomorrow,” it will also have to quickly prove that it can serve as a springboard for an intelligent urban policy on the scale of the country as a whole, and thus catch up with its European neighbours.
This article was originally published in French.



