An employee was excluded from his company’s collective agreement because he was regarded as a senior manager. The Court of Appeal rejected this classification, ruling in particular that his salary was not high enough. As a result, his employer must pay him €58,067. (Photo: Shutterstock)

An employee was excluded from his company’s collective agreement because he was regarded as a senior manager. The Court of Appeal rejected this classification, ruling in particular that his salary was not high enough. As a result, his employer must pay him €58,067. (Photo: Shutterstock)

An employee was excluded from his company’s collective agreement because he was considered a senior manager. The Court of Appeal rejected this classification, ruling in particular that his salary was not high enough. As a result, his employer must pay him €58,067.

Senior management status does not depend solely on the title stated in an employment contract. This is highlighted by a case brought to light on Tuesday 11 August by the Chamber of Employees (CSL) in the latest issue of “InfosJuridiques”, which focuses on several recent decisions in employment law. In a judgement of 30 April 2026, the Court of Appeal considered the case of a legal counsel whose contract classified her as an “exempt employee”, in other words, a senior manager. This classification excluded him from the scope of his company’s collective agreement and, consequently, from the profit-sharing scheme it provided for. After leaving the company in 2021, the employee challenged this status in order to be eligible for this benefit.

The issue of pay

The Court of Appeal ruled in his favour on this point, having examined, in particular, his remuneration. To be regarded as a senior manager within the meaning of the Labour Code, an employee must receive a salary that is “significantly higher” than that of comparable employees covered by the collective agreement, in addition to meeting other criteria. In this case, his gross monthly remuneration taken into account amounted to €6,756.73, including benefits in kind. This exceeded that of a comparable employee covered by the collective agreement by just over 10% at the end of 2020, and by less than 7% in September 2021. According to the Court, this difference was insufficient to meet the criterion of “significantly higher” remuneration.

As this single condition was not met, the Court held that the employee could not be classified as a senior manager, without needing to examine the other criteria. He was therefore entitled to rely on the collective agreement and claim the corresponding “profit-sharing”. Taking into account his periods of part-time work and the bonus already received, he is entitled to €28,005.15 for 2020 and €30,062.18 for 2021. By overturning the judgment at first instance, the Court of Appeal ultimately ordered the company to pay him €58,067.33.