Michel Simonis, the director general, and Dominique Hansen, director of communications and fundraising, note a sharp drop in donations in 2024. Photo: Croix-Rouge luxembourgeoise

Michel Simonis, the director general, and Dominique Hansen, director of communications and fundraising, note a sharp drop in donations in 2024. Photo: Croix-Rouge luxembourgeoise

The Red Cross presented its 2024 activity report on 12 June. The highlight was a 19.37% drop in donations, which is linked to the fallout from the Caritas affair. It’s an affair that should prompt all members of the humanitarian sector to adopt even more exemplary conduct, says Red Cross director general Michel Simonis.

In comparison with 2023, when it raised €5.856m, the Red Cross recorded donations of €4.738m in 2024. This represents a drop of 19.37%. A lesser evil if we consider that during the summer of 2024--at the height of the Caritas affair--donations fell by more than 40%.

Has confidence returned? Luxembourg Red Cross director general Michel SimonisMichel Simonis thinks so. “Over the year, 16,000 people will have made a gesture or several gestures, including 3,500 for the first time.” In total, 28,224 donations were made. “In the end, it was a good year,” he says. “The level of collections remains comparable to previous years.”

€4.738m is still a far cry from the record set in 2022, when the Red Cross received €7.856m. “This was a record due to the outbreak of war in Ukraine, a crisis that had generated a particularly large solidarity movement. Major humanitarian crises are naturally conducive to donations, as we saw with Ukraine and with the earthquakes that hit Turkey and Syria. From a domestic point of view, it’s children and young people that mobilise people. And these are also two of the Luxembourg Red Cross’s most developed areas of action.”

“The sums are used to finance actions in accordance with the wishes of the donors.” In the case of Ukraine, Luxembourg teams have been deployed and are working with the Ukrainian Red Cross. Efforts are focused on the reconstruction and rehabilitation of damaged health facilities. As for Gaza, the other humanitarian tragedy in the news, the sums raised are being used to finance actions carried out by local associations under the aegis of the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC). Whilst the Luxembourg Red Cross works on the ground in 10 countries in Africa, Asia and Europe, it has no plans for direct involvement in Palestine.

If we were ever faced with a major problem, we would only last a few months, despite our assets.
Michel Simonis

Michel Simonis, director general, Luxembourg Red Cross

Is this drop in donations likely to jeopardise the existence of the Luxembourg Red Cross? Not a priori, if we compare this €5m to the €350m in income received in 2024. However, this financial ratio is misleading, explains Simonis, for whom these donations are--in a way--the association’s “own funds.”

“The funds we collect from institutional backers--whether the state, local authorities, social security or European institutions--are funds that have already been spent when the agreements are signed. They are not operating expenses. That’s why donations are essential if we are to operate. If they decrease, we can dip into our reserves, but that would be the beginning of a descent into hell. Admittedly, with a balance sheet of €495m, we’re not a poor organisation, but with our size--3,500 employees--if we were ever faced with a major problem, we would only last a few months, despite our assets. What’s more, these reserves enable us to respond to day-to-day problems, via our solidarity fund in particular, and to major crises, even before we raise funds or approach our public backers.”

It was these reserves that also ensured that, despite the collapse of Caritas, there was no interruption of services to the beneficiaries of actions carried out jointly by the Red Cross and the defunct Caritas until Hëllef um Terrain (HUT) took over its activities. This mainly involves the management of social grocery shops--there are 12 in the country, eight under the Red Cross and four under Caritas--and the management of Wanteraktioun.

Demand for transparency

The Caritas affair has also had an impact on the governance of the humanitarian sector. “This is an issue we are working hard on. We have seen how essential it is, as a humanitarian organisation, to be transparent and to behave in an exemplary way. Any failure by an organisation working in the social sector--and not just Caritas--has an impact on the other players, and trust is always hard to regain. We want to be responsible in our management and governance.” And whilst he believes that the safeguards in place are adequate, Simonis acknowledges that there is no such thing as zero risk and that the institution as such is a target.

Another impact of the affair is on relations with the banks. “They are now more demanding.” The presumption of respectability that the banks and Caritas mentioned when they appeared before the special parliamentary committee, and which the major players in the humanitarian sector enjoyed, is dead. “But if the banks are stricter with us, we are also stricter with them. We demand that the services we have contracted with them are properly carried out. This was not the case with Caritas. And we are equally demanding of our auditors, who now have even greater responsibilities under the new law on ASBLs. We really expect the auditors to come and see what’s going on in the field and get a clear idea of what we’re doing.”

Other highlights of the year

The central theme is the fight against precariousness. And this precariousness is increasing, notes Simonis, at the same time as the gaps are widening with well-off households. “Twenty-six percent of households with children struggle to make ends meet.” This precarious situation is partly due to the “very heavy financial burden on households linked to housing, whether they rent or own their own home.” Faced with this challenge, the Red Cross has stepped up its efforts to promote inclusion, whether through its social grocery shops, which were used by 39,380 people in 2024 (+4.10%), its cloakroom, which was used by 5,137 people (+22%), its Solidarity Fund, which granted 329 subsidies (+11%), or its social services (6,078 cases monitored, compared with 7,064 in 2023). “Adapting the size of the organisation to meet needs is a challenge,” sums up the director general.

On the housing front, the other current priority, the Red Cross has helped to house 864 people. The association directly manages 275 rental units, 135 of which are managed on a social rental basis (gestion locative sociale, or GLS). The GLS combines three tools: a rent payment guarantee; social and educational support; and technical housing aids. Following a bequest of €50m made in 2023 by the lawyer Robert Schuman, €200m will be invested between now and 2030 to build affordable housing--€50m will come from the bequest, backed by €150m in public funding. One hundred and sixty-eight homes will be built, with the first 25 to be delivered by the end of the year. It should be noted here that bequests, unlike donations, are recorded directly on the association’s balance sheet.

This article was originally published in French.