Frank Engel and his allies are challengers to grab the 44% or voters who have no partisan affiliation to a political party, says Philippe Poirier. Romain Gamba / Maison Moderne

Frank Engel and his allies are challengers to grab the 44% or voters who have no partisan affiliation to a political party, says Philippe Poirier. Romain Gamba / Maison Moderne

Frank Engel, who will present his new political party today, will have to prove its usefulness to the general public, says political scientist Philippe Poirier. Especially since political party splits have so far not resulted in success in Luxembourg.

Following his abrupt resignation as party president at the CSV in March last year, Frank Engel had announced he would create a new political entity. That promise finally comes into being on 21 February when Engel presents his new party. Former secretary general of the DP Marc Ruppert, former DP member Gary Kneip and former municipal councillor of Esch-sur-Alzette Luc Majerus have already been confirmed as future members of Engel's party. 

The emergence of a new party ahead of the 2023 legislative elections is not surprising. “Since the 1970s, every legislative election has been marked by the creation of political parties, often splits of pre-existing parties,” says Philippe Poirier.

Frequent splits

Following a political split linked to the LSAP, the short-lived Social Democratic Party (PSD) was created in 1971. The Green Party also experienced this phenomenon in the 1980s and 1990s. It split, then reunited before splitting again. In 2017 the dei Konservativ movement emerged after splitting from the ADR. Meanwhile, Volt--a trans-European political party--was founded by former members of the DP and CSV ahead of the 2019 European elections.

Except for the PSD, which won a few seats in parliament before falling apart in 1983, these attempts to split away have always ended in failure. “No breakaway party has succeeded in making a strong and lasting impact on political life,” says Poirier. “They either came back into the fold or disappear.”

Partisan disaffiliation

Engel's new party could, however, benefit from recent societal developments. “From the 1970s until the mid-2000s, due to stable individual and collective values, socio-political division was fixed in Luxembourg society. The electorate remained very loyal to political parties,” says Poirier. “But, since about 2005, there has been more partisan instability due to the transformation of values.”

In fact, according to a study carried out in 2021 in Luxembourg, 44% of those questioned said they no longer had any partisan ties. “Mr Engel and his allies are, like others, potential challengers to try to grab this 44%,” says Poirier. After 10 years of mixed fortunes for the three-party DP-LSAP-déi Gréng coalition, there might be an opportunity for Engel to pick up votes from disillusioned voters.

Building on strong demands

Under these conditions, electoral “coups” are more likely to get a result, and perhaps even win a seat or two. “But we shouldn't expect an electoral boom,” says Poirier. “The law on political parties and the electoral law, split voting [whereby voters can choose candidates from different parties] and the four constituencies, favour the incumbent parties,” he adds.

In any case, creating a breakaway party is not enough on its own. Frank Engel will have to present a consistent and innovative programme on Monday. “If it's about creating another DP or CSV, without any fundamental differences, voters won't be interested at first sight. It has to be based on demands that run through society,” says Poirier.

What use is it to society?

Having a real usefulness for voters is an important element in the survival of parties that have emerged in recent decades. The Green Party, for example, was based on ecology, which emerged in the 1980s. The ADR was formed around the issue of pension inequalities between the public and private sectors, a key issue in the Luxembourg political system. “Today, they defend conservatism, sovereignty, Euroscepticism and question identity and immigration, issues that are now very important in Luxembourg society,” says Poirier. The Pirate Party, which was born out of specific demands on computer freedoms and transparency, has since diversified and will have to reinforce its image during the next legislative elections, but it is also based on a real demand from society.

The question that Engel and his allies will have to answer is: what is the usefulness of this formation for the general public in Luxembourg? “If they provide a real answer, it could hinder the DP and the CSV", says Philippe Poirier. “But if there is no answer, then this party will remain an association of dissidents.”

This story was first published in French on Paperjam. It has been translated and edited for Delano.