According to an audit carried out in summer 2021, 475 of the 1.787 pedestrian crossings in Luxembourg City do not comply with the highway code. Photo: Shutterstock

According to an audit carried out in summer 2021, 475 of the 1.787 pedestrian crossings in Luxembourg City do not comply with the highway code. Photo: Shutterstock

After nearly four years of legal wrangling, the highest administrative court has ruled that the City of Luxembourg must provide the Zentrum fir Urban Gerechtegkeet (Zug, or Center for Urban Justice) with all documents relating to its analysis of pedestrian crossings, as well as access--even partial access--to its database of road markings. A victory hailed for administrative transparency and the right of access to information.

A head pokes around the boot of a car. To cross or not to cross? Seen by the motorist, not seen? According to an audit carried out in the summer of 2021, 475 of the 1,787 pedestrian crossings in Luxembourg City do not comply with the highway code.

In the context of its apparently innocuous request made by the Zug as part of this “Safe Crossing” audit, aimed at assessing the compliance of pedestrian crossings with safety rules, the citizens’ association had met with a categorical refusal from the city, which invoked arguments of confidentiality, security and even technical irregularity to withhold the documents.

The ruling, handed down at the beginning of June, sweeps aside these justifications. The administrative court considers that a document cited in a public meeting by an elected representative--in this case, the alderman for mobility, Patrick GoldschmidtPatrick Goldschmidt (DP)--loses its internal status and de facto becomes a public document. It also rejects the argument that an imperfect or constantly evolving database could not be consulted, stating that information describing a factual situation at a given moment does fall within the right to information.

Most importantly, the court declared inadmissible the city’s allegations that the Zug’s requests could have posed a national security problem.

The case also highlighted a troubling contradiction. Goldschmidt had justified the municipal interpretation of the highway code by a supposed agreement with the ministry of mobility and public works, but no document confirms the existence of such an agreement, much to the astonishment of the judges. “If no one can produce the document, the courts will not continue to believe it,” the Zug points out in its statement.

Beyond the textbook case, this decision set a powerful precedent: administrations can no longer hide behind “eternal drafts” or databases allegedly too complex to escape public scrutiny, the Zug further analyses.

The Zug now plans to finalise its audit of pedestrian crossings--in particular to strictly enforce the five-metre rule between a crossing and an intersection--and relaunch its participatory platform SafeCrossing.app in summer 2025. The organisation also plans to create a fund to support journalists, researchers and associations in their efforts to access public information.

In a response Thursday evening, the City of Luxembourg stated that it had forwarded the association’s lawyer the internal documents. It also noted that it had made a database available for consultation at city hall on 6 April 2022, an opportunity the association never took advantage of. The municipality said it was awaiting a response before setting a date.

This article was originally published in French.