Luxembourg MP Franz Fayot is one of the 5 November debate participants
 Elvinger, Hoss & Prussen

Luxembourg MP Franz Fayot is one of the 5 November debate participants  Elvinger, Hoss & Prussen

Are we any closer to really understanding the implications of the 2008 financial crisis and its impact on the global and local economy? Some economies recovered, but too many euro zone countries are seeing output fall and unemployment rise. And are we prepared for the next crisis?

“Economic crisis: have we learned the right lessons?” will be the motion discussed by the first Oxford Union Debate organised by the Paperjam Club (owned by Delano’s publisher) on Wednesday in Luxembourg City.

The Oxford Union was founded in that UK university town in 1823, providing a forum and training ground for generations of political and cultural leaders. Speakers give presentations for and against a proposition, before moving on to an open debate. The audience are then invited to vote for the side with the most convincing arguments.

Speaking for the motion will be Yves Nosbusch, chief economist of BGL BNP Paribas and Jean-Pierre Zigrand, an associate professor at the London School of Economics. Against will be Luxembourg Socialist Workers’ Party member of the Chamber of Deputies Franz Fayot and Nicolas Henckes, secretary general of the Union of Luxembourg Enterprises. The moderator will be the current president of the Oxford Union Society, Ben Sullivan.

European Central Bank

Economists are still debating the causes and cures of the 1930s Great Depression, so it would be surprising if everyone agreed about the way forward after 2008. “The European Central Bank has now taken the view that more stimulus is required and we are seeing that policy rolled out now,” Nosbusch told Delano prior to the event. In this way, the ECB is now aligning itself more with actions taken by the US Federal Reserve.

If the experts can’t agree, then there is even less clarity amongst voters. “There has been a temptation to blame the banks for the crisis but mainstream opinion realises the crisis is complex with many causes,” added Nosbusch.

There has been the anti-capitalist rage of the Occupy movement, but the more mainstream response has been greater regulation. The move to force banks to hold greater reserves to ward off future crises has been widely supported. However some believe that too much regulation risks making banking clients too complacent and willing to take excessive risks with their savings.

Slow growth

On the Luxembourg level, Nicolas Henckes is worried that governments have not changed course since the downturn. Growth has slowed and unemployment keeps rising. Jobs are being created but too often locally based job-candidates lack skills, so employers are turning to new immigrants and cross border commuters.

“You are seeing French people with university degrees willing to drive two hours round trip to Luxembourg for relatively menial jobs,” said Henckes. He explains this saying the Luxembourgish minimum wage is higher than average salary in France.

He also thinks more should be done to reduce the cost of living, with him recommending strong measures to moderate the cost of housing.