Pierre Etienne
 LaLa La Photo

Pierre Etienne  LaLa La Photo

There is no independently verifiable way of measuring the impact since banking secrecy was ended on 1 January, but the industry is upbeat about the move. Late last year, national statistics office Statec had estimated that assets in the wealth management business could fall by about 5% this year, with some industry players privately fearing a drop of one-tenth.

“The Statec study was based on a number of projections and hypotheses that in the meantime have strongly improved,” noted Pierre Etienne, the recently appointed head of the Private Banking Group Luxembourg. He did not put any figures to this, but pointed to a “new kind of business coming into Luxembourg” and improved market performance.

Secrecy was a key factor encouraging non-residents to hide cash in Luxembourg banks, mainly as a way of avoiding taxes in their home countries. Luxembourg and other EU countries had resisted attempts to change arguing that this would lead to the cash flowing to Switzerland. Yet after the 2007-08 financial crisis the international political pressure become too great, so most financial centres decided to sign up to EU and OECD rules on sharing information about non-residents’ savings with foreign tax offices.

Some banks have been hard hit by this, and were forced to close or be sold. The total in this country fell from 152 in April 2014, to 141 a year later, rising slightly to 143 in August. It is not clear how much of this can be explained by the end of banking secrecy, or just the general falling profitability of banking as a business.

However, most banks involved in wealth management decided to change their focus, offering services that were both legal and but also helped save tax. The problem is that these sophisticated, cross-border solutions come at a cost, so are only appropriate for those with at least half a million to invest.

Change of focus

“Luxembourg attracts more and more fully tax compliant wealthy clients, let’s say with wealth above €5m,” noted Etienne. Whilst he sees this as “a very good sign for the future of that business in our country,” he sees an outflow of “smaller clients which were historically more profitable than the wealthy client.”

Banking profits have been under pressure since the crisis, often due to new regulations and laws, and it is no different for private banking. A PBGL report pointed to private banking assets under management reaching €318bn at the end of last year, a 4% increase, but employment in the sector fell 4%, twice as quickly as the drop seen across the entire banking industry.

While the picture is mixed for the economic outcome, what about the effect on the country’s image? Criticism of Luxembourg and other small financial centres has increased since the crisis, but ending the easy to understand bank secrecy policy has probably helped Luxembourg’s defenders.

It does not make the country immune from bad press though. Even when engaging in perfectly legal and transparent financial planning, the country can get it in the neck, as was seen during the “LuxLeaks” story that broke in late 2014 about international firms avoiding tax. Although this affair has nothing to do with banking secrecy, it shows that there is probably little small financial centres can do to avoid being attacked from time to time.

From the October print edition