The grand chamber at the European Court of Justice in Kirchberg
 Marco Galasso/Creative Commons (2012)

The grand chamber at the European Court of Justice in Kirchberg  Marco Galasso/Creative Commons (2012)

European member states must recognise resident cards issued by another EU country under “freedom of movement” principles, the EU’s top court has ruled. The judgement issued in Luxembourg said that Britain cannot impose visa requirements on non-EU family members of EU citizens who live elsewhere in the EU when they visit the UK, unless authorities have specific doubts about the document.

The case stems from a complaint filed by the McCarthy family, who live in Spain. Helena Patricia McCarthy Rodriguez is a Colombian citizen and holds a valid Spanish residence permit, according to court documents. Her husband and daughter are both British nationals, and she frequently travels with them to the UK to see family and for her husband’s medical visits.

As a non-EU national, this requires Mrs McCarthy, before her trips, to secure a “family permit”. The document is valid for six months at a time and must be renewed in person at a UK diplomatic mission, a nine to 11 hour round-trip for Mrs McCarthy.

The British government “accepts that in this case there is no question of there being a sham marriage,” but contended that issuing family permits is required because EU resident permits “vary greatly” and that applications must be done in-person to avoid identity fraud.

In 2012 the family filed a complaint before an administrative tribunal at the High Court of Justice (England & Wales) arguing the British policy goes against European rules. Under the “Free Movement Directive, non-EU family members of an EU citizen who hold a residence permit for an EU country cannot be subjected to visa requirements to enter another EU state,” according to a court summary.

The High Court then asked the European Court of Justice in Kirchberg if the family permit system was permitted under Britain’s right to exercise border controls.

Family member rights

On Thursday, the judges ruled that it was not. Member states must recognise resident permits issued by other EU countries “unless doubt is cast on the authenticity of that card and the correctness of the data appearing on it by concrete evidence which, in relation to the individual case, justifies the conclusion that there is an abuse of rights or fraud,” the ECJ said.

The British rules require “an entry permit to be obtained prior to entry into UK territory, even where the authorities do not consider that the family member of an EU citizen may be involved in an abuse of rights or fraud. Family members who possess a valid residence card are thus prevented absolutely and automatically by the legislation from entering the territory of the member states without a visa, although that right of entry is conferred on them by [a 2004 European] directive.”

The matter now returns to the UK court for adjudication.

The case was C-202/13 McCarthy and Others.