The proposed regime “UCITS V” is designed to prevent fraud like Bernard Madoff’s Ponzi scheme, in which investors were defrauded of more than US$10 billion. Four Luxembourg-based UCITS retail investment funds collapsed as a result of losses in Madoff’s firm, according to Bloomberg News data, while litigation involving dozens more continue.
The European Commission presented its three-pronged plan on Tuesday. If the programme is approved, UCITS funds--the heart of the Grand Duchy’s financial sector--will face uniform rules on the penalties that can be imposed on fund managers by national regulators. In addition, rules will link fund manager pay with long-term performance so that “the way they are remunerated should not encourage excessive risk-taking,” the commission told the press.
The scheme also spells out a single, pan-European body of procedural and liability requirements for funds’ depositary banks, which are responsible for safeguarding the money investors place in UCITS funds. Currently those rules are implemented in slightly different ways by each of the EU27’s national regulators.
Insurance and “packaged” products
The commission said that “more than 70% of insurance products are sold without appropriate advice.” Brussels proposed Europe-wide rules aimed at providing better conflicts-of-interest disclosure and increased cross-border competition.
The third main area of reform involves “packaged” financial products, such as insurance-based investments and private pension plans, which will now be required to provide consumers with a “key information document” that describes things like risk and cost in simple and standardised language. The UCITS fund industry implemented similar rules last year as part of the last set of European regulations, “UCITS IV.”
“In the aftermath of the biggest financial crisis in recent memory, the financial sector must place consumers at its heart,” Michel Barnier, European commissioner for internal market and services (photo), said in a statement. “Retail products must be safer, information standards must become clearer, and those selling products must always be subject to the highest standards.”
Luxembourg’s funds industry trade group ALFI said that it “welcomes the general thrust of the proposed text,” agreeing that harmonised rules were good for the industry. However the association warned “that if depositaries are held liable for investment losses in all circumstances, they become ‘insurers’ for risks beyond their control” and the costs for the scheme will ultimately be passed on to consumers. In addition, “there may be a moral hazard associated with investors believing their investment is risk-free,” ALFI told the press on Tuesday.
The European Commission proposal now goes to the European Parliament and the council of European governments for consideration.
