A European Parliament vote on new mutual fund regulations has been delayed over disagreements on compensation limits for retail investment fund managers.
The parliament’s economic and monetary affairs committee first voted in favour of a bonus cap in March, but since then committee members have been unable to agree on proposed amendments to the text.
Proponents had originally wanted the full, or plenary, vote to already have been held by now.
The committee now plans a new vote during its June 17-18 session with a vote by the full parliament scheduled for the first week of July, a spokesman for committee member Robert Goebbels, a Luxembourg LSAP MEP, told Delano on Wednesday. “The main sticking points are… bonus caps and performance fees,” he said.
Bonuses for managers of Ucits, or European cross-border mutual funds, will be capped at 100% of annual salary in most cases, under the draft bill. Half of bonuses would have to be paid in shares of the Ucits run by the manager.
Members of the European People’s Party bloc, which includes Luxembourg’s CSV party, have voted against the measure.
Search for consumer protection compromise
“I asked for the postponement of the debate and vote of the UCITS V dossier in plenary in order to continue political negotiations,” Sven Giegold (photo), who chairs committee discussions on the bill, told Delano on Thursday. “We are trying to figure out if a pro-European and cross-party compromise for water proof consumer protection rules in the area of managers’ remuneration and performance fee regulations can be found,” the German Green MEP said.
The committee has “voted to cap bonuses for fund managers and employees with an influence on investment decisions to the maximum of fixed remuneration. Twenty-four months of pay should be a more than sufficient incentive for fund managers and employees to successfully carry out their duties. This crucial provision will help strengthen investor protection and reduce risky speculation. It will also complement the recently adopted EU rules capping bankers’ bonuses, ensuring these rules cannot be circumvented and providing for a level playing field,” he explained.
“The rules also include wider provisions significantly limiting performance fees for management companies. These opaque fees for management companies are a rip-off for investors, unfairly reducing their income from funds,” according to Giegold.
“The bonus cap for the banks should be extended to Ucits. It is very hard to argue against. This will ensure a level playing field with the banking industry and reduce systemic risk by avoiding the bonus cap on banks from being circumvented.”
Industry faces multiple regulations
In an interview with Delano after the March vote, Anouk Agnes of the industry trade group Alfi said the fund sector would like to “have some sort of consistency” on compensation rules. She noted the numerous sets of discreet EU rules that tackle the question. “This issue is already addressed in MiFid, AIFMD, CRD, UCITS V; so many directives talk about the issue of remuneration that we are a bit frightened of the [number of] different regimes. We are not against the discussion, but it should be consistent between the different regimes.”
“Ucits are very transparent, with lots of checks and balances” already in place, Agnes added.
Ucits control nearly €6.3 trillion in funds, according to the parliament, of which more than 30% is domiciled in Luxembourg, according to fund industry trade group Efama.
The EU is seeking to finalise the fifth generation of the rules, whose creation in the 1980s turned the Grand Duchy into the world’s second largest mutual fund centre.
After the parliament agrees to the bill, it then must be approved by the European Commission and the Council of European finance ministers.
“In either case the European Parliament will have a negotiation position” with the commission and council “before the summer retreat,” Giegold told Delano. “I hope the outgoing Irish presidency and incoming Lithuanian presidency will put the file back on their agenda so we can come to a conclusion soon.”
