The European Parliament has voted down a plan to extend the EU’s bonus cap from bankers to retail investment fund managers.
Since early spring the parliament had been debating a proposal that would have limited “variable compensation” for managers of Ucits, or European cross-border mutual funds, to a maximum of 100% of annual salary in most cases.
On Wednesday, the parliament, sitting in Strasbourg, narrowly rejected the amendment, passing the so-called “Ucits V” bill without the bonus ceiling.
The parliament’s final version did call for EU states to “require” fund firms “to establish and apply remuneration policies and practices that are consistent with and promote sound and effective risk management and do not encourage risk-taking which is inconsistent with the risk profiles, rules or instruments of incorporation of the Ucits they manage”.
The measure also calls for half of bonuses to be paid in shares of the Ucits run by the manager, and 40% of “variable remuneration would be deferred, to encourage managers to take a long-run view”.
In addition, “where a Ucits loses money, its managers’ remuneration would be reduced or even clawed back”, according to parliament documents.
New depositary rules
Separately, the bill set-up uniform liability requirements for funds’ depositary banks, which are responsible for safeguarding the money investors place in Ucits funds. Currently those rules are implemented in slightly different ways by each of the EU28’s national regulators.
According to the parliament: “Depositaries would be required not to act without authorisation and would have to keep investors’ money clearly separate from their own assets. They would be barred from using these funds as collateral in other transactions or investing them on their own account.”
Ucits control nearly €6.3 trillion in funds, according to the parliament, of which more than 30% is domiciled in Luxembourg, according to fund industry trade group Efama.
Following the vote, the association said in a press statement that the bill “is testament to the importance the European Parliament places on Ucits and investors’ protection”.
Marc Saluzzi, chair of Luxembourg fund industry association Alfi, told Delano on Thursday that the organisation “was satisfied with the results” of the vote.
“Dark day” or “benefit” for investors?
But in a separate press statement, Sven Giegold, the German Green MEP who chaired debate on the bill (photo), called Wednesday’s vote: “A dark day for the protection of investors in Europe. A majority of conservatives and liberals have largely thwarted steps for financial stability and improved investor protection with investment funds.”
Giegold blamed “the German investment lobby” and a “right-wing majority” for helping perpetuate “opaque fees” that “create no value and are therefore nothing more than blatant rip-off at the expense of investors”.
The bill will now be finalised in three-way talks between the parliament, the European Commission and the Council of European finance ministers.
Efama director general Peter de Proft said in a press statement that the group “wishes the final directive to deliver a good result for end-investors in relation to the safeguarding of assets and other provisions that benefit end-investors.”
Saluzzi told Delano that Alfi would continue to work--via Efama, in order to speak with a unified industry voice--with EU leaders to “arrive at the best balance possible to preserve the interests of our industry, naturally, and the protection of our investors.”
However, Giegold warned that in the future safeguards could simply “be circumvented thanks to Christian Democrats and Liberals who continue to keep company with funds in Luxembourg”.
