Paperjam.lu

 Olivier Minaire (archives)

The EU’s top court said music played during dental treatment was not a “communication to the public”--the legal benchmark that triggers royalty payments--since recordings are only meant for a single patient to hear at a one time. The Kirchberg-based court also noted that music was not part of the profit-making operations of dental practices.

The case (C-135/10) was brought by Italy’s royalty collection agency, Società Consortile Fonografici, against a Turin dentist, Marco Del Corso.

Immediately after that ruling, the ECJ ruled that hotel operators must pay music royalties, as “indeterminate” number of guests stay in their rooms, and audio-visual equipment are provided as part of their profit-making activity.

The second case (C-162/10) was brought by Ireland’s royalty agency, Phonographic Performance (Ireland) Limited, against the Irish government, who had not enforced its collection requests.

Both matters now go back to courts in their respective countries for final adjudication.