Paperjam.lu

 Staff (archives)

Luxembourg should not be required to include children of cross-border commuters in its university financial aid programme, according to a preliminary opinion at the European Court of Justice.

The Grand Duchy’s higher education ministry has denied subsidy requests from more than 600 such University of Luxembourg students, including Elodie Giersch who filed a complaint before the Administrative Court of Luxembourg.

Giersch and her fellow students have claimed the policy is discriminatory and hinders the free movement of people within Europe, since the children of “frontalier” are treated differently than children of residents.

The Grand Duchy has argued that provision of education is a national matter--meaning the students are considered financially part of their parents’ households--and the university subsidy is part of Luxembourg’s economic diversification programme, not a social benefit.

The administrative court asked the European Court of Justice in Kirchberg if the rules, set up in 2010, fell afoul of European law.

Luxembourg wins initial ruling

On Thursday Paolo Mengozzi, one of the court’s eight advocates general, said that Luxembourg’s residency requirement is most likely justified.

In Mengozzi’s opinion, “the transition towards a knowledge-based economy” could warrant “the discriminatory practice at issue” otherwise it would be impossible for the government to reach its policy goal.

However, it is up to Luxembourg’s national court system “to verify” the programme is “seriously and effectively implemented” and therefore will ultimately “enrich the Luxembourg labour market”.

The matter will now be considered by a full panel of judges. In the majority of cases judges reach the same conclusion as the advocate general, although their decision will be separate from last week’s opinion. No date has yet been scheduled for this ruling.

After the ECJ issues its decision, the suit will return to Luxembourg’s administrative court for final adjudication.

The case is number C-20/12 (Elodie Giersch and others v Luxembourg).