European privacy officials have asked the three largest internet search firms to explain how they are handling data deletion requests following a ruling by the EU’s top court.
Earlier this year the European Court of Justice said that EU residents have the “right to be forgotten” online and can ask search engines (although not the original publisher) to remove search results about them. The companies must review the requests themselves. Individuals can then lodge appeals to national data privacy agencies, such as the CNPD in Luxembourg, if the firm declines the request.
Representatives of Google, Microsoft and Yahoo attended a summit with a group of EU data protection authorities last week in Brussels, according to a European Commission communiqué issued on Friday.
“The objective of this meeting was to ask search engines about their practical implementation of the ruling,” in order to develop guidelines for EU national agencies to handle appeals when the search engines refuse to delist links. The aim of the rulebook is “ensuring a consistent handling of complaints” across Europe, the commission stated.
Data protection officials asked the internet firms, among other questions, what information European residents had to provide when asking for a link to be removed, “the legal basis for excluding” requests, if website publishers are notified when links are removed, and if results are filtered only within Europe or globally.
Europe-only results
Google “came under fire by regulators” after it only removed links on its European sites, a source told Reuters last week. That means internet users of the company’s American website, for example, can still find suppressed links.
Google has approved more than half of the 90,000 requests it has received, has asked for more details in about 15% of cases, and has rejected roughly 30% of applications, the news agency reported the source as saying.
As of this writing, Google representatives had not returned Delano’s messages seeking comment.
A spokeswoman for Microsoft told Delano on Friday that: “On July 15 we launched an online form for residents of the European Economic Area and Switzerland to request blocks of specific privacy-related search results on Bing in light of the recent ruling by the European Court of Justice. Implementing the decision is a complicated process. We are continuously working out the details of this process, including the way we will proceed to evaluate the requests we receive from users.”
A spokeswoman for Yahoo said the company did not have any comment at this time.
More questions
During the Brussels meeting, EU data regulators asked the three firms a set of 19 detailed technical and process questions that need to be answered by the end of the month.
As of this writing representatives of the commission had not returned Delano’s message inquiring when the draft guidelines for EU agencies will be published.
The rules could be issued by mid-September, according to the Reuters report.
