Jane Wilkinson
 Steve Eastwood

Jane Wilkinson  Steve Eastwood

Luxembourg is the European leader in “responsible investment funds”. Good news, because this market appears to be growing strongly and has substantial untapped potential. But what exactly is responsible investment?

Judging a good from a bad fund is normally relatively straightforward: good ones make more money than the bad ones. Determining if the fund goes beyond this to produce wider benefits is tricky for a number of reasons. What makes an investment more or less “responsible”? Who will judge whether this is so and who will check that promises are being kept? Does pursuing these ends lead to lower financial returns?

The third edition of the “European Responsible Investing Fund Survey” was commissioned by the Association of the Luxembourg Fund Industry to add greater precision. The results were presented at their spring conference by Jane Wilkinson of KPMG Luxembourg, the consulting firm which conducted the survey.

Cutting through jargon

“Some see this as a wishy-washy idea, lacking real substance and designed to apply ‘greenwash’ to an investment strategy,” she told the conference. She believes that this is unfair, and that the false impression is partly due to the broad range of possibilities and complex jargon attached to this area of activity. Hence, the report began by giving structure to the concept.

Under the banner of “responsible investing” (RI) are five categories which favour different priorities: environment, social, governance, ethical and cross-sectoral funds. So an environmental fund might target climate change technologies or sustainable forestry. Microfinance funds typically help families in the developing world access loans of a few hundred euros, and they are classed as “social” funds. Then, faith-based funds (most notably Islamic funds) are what is meant by “ethical” funds.

It becomes more complicated still. It might seem obvious to exclude investments in firms with a track record of using child labour. However, what if that firm also has schools and other social programmes that improve the lives of their staff? Energy companies pump oil and this leads to climate change, but what if they also invest billions in researching green fuels? The solution is that funds must be as open about their strategies as possible so that investors can make an informed decision.

Luxembourg leads France

These grey areas make it difficult to arrive at clear statistics, but nevertheless, the report shows that the Grand Duchy is in a clear lead in a growing market. European RI fund assets have almost doubled since 2010, reaching €372bn in 2014. Of this, about one third are based in Luxembourg--twice the figure of the next largest centre (France) and more than three times third-placed Norway.

Wilkinson pointed out that responsible investing could be considered the third pillar of the Luxembourg industry, behind UCITS (retail) and alternative funds. At the moment, this sector accounts for about 4% of all regulated assets based here, but continued strong growth could increase this share. Increased popularity of these products would be good news for this country, which has substantial expertise in running complicated fund structures. Plus being the centre for responsible investment funds would help the Luxembourg brand image.

These issues and more will be examined at the Impact Investing and Microfinance Conference organised by ALFI on 29 April.

Download the 3rd “European Responsible Investing Fund Survey” from the ALFI website.