Mario Draghi, speaking at a 2014 press conference
 European Central Bank

Mario Draghi, speaking at a 2014 press conference  European Central Bank

Mario Draghi, the head of the European Central Bank, had the authority to say that he would “do whatever it takes” to save the euro, a legal advisor at the EU’s top court has concluded in a preliminary ruling.

While it is “unconventional”, the Frankfurt-based institution can take “exceptional measures” to aid euro area countries hit hard by the financial crisis that started in 2008, according to Pedro Cruz Villalón, one of the eight advocates general at the European Court of Justice in Kirchberg.

The ECJ procedures stem from a case before the Bundesverfassungsgericht, Germany’s constitutional court, filed by several parties, including Peter Gauweiler, a CSU (conservative) member of the Bundestag, Germany’s lower house of parliament, and the Bundestag faction of the left wing political party Die Linke. They claimed that Germany’s federal government failed to take action against the ECB, when it should have done so.

The ECB exceeded its authority when it announced it was ready to conduct “outright monetary transactions”, also called “quantitative easing”, in September 2012, the plaintiffs have argued. OMT is the unlimited direct purchase of bonds issued by governments participating in a pair of European bailout programmes, the group has claimed.

The central bank has not yet made any OMT purchases, but is under pressure to do so.

The German court asked the ECJ last February if the ECB policy is consistent with EU law and the court held hearings in October.

ECB has “exclusive competence”

On Wednesday, the ECJ advocate general said quantitative easing was completely within the bank’s authority, provided it provides additional information to the public.

The ECB, under European treaties, has “exclusive competence in respect of monetary policy”, Cruz Villalón stated in his opinion. “The ECB enjoys a broad discretion in the definition and implementation of monetary policy. The Court of Justice should acknowledge that broad discretion and recognise the objectives which the ECB set forth when announcing its OMT programme,” he recommended.

Cruz Villalón noted that the ECB had not fully published its rationale and action plan for conducing OMT. If it engages in such operations, the central bank will then have to release an “explanation of the reasons on which a public decision is based” that will be subject, if needed, to court scrutiny, the advocate general reasoned. “It will be possible to review the validity of that programme only when the [the ECB’s] governing council formally adopts the programme and publishes it”.

In addition, Cruz Villalón did not see quantitative easing as a back-door economic stimulus package, which would be outside the central bank’s purview.

“I consider that the OMT programme is to be regarded as a monetary policy measure, provided that the ECB refrains--once the time has come to put that programme into effect--from any direct involvement in the financial assistance programmes of the ESM or the EFSF.”

The two EU bailout agencies are the European Financial Stability Facility, a temporary agency that supported troubled euro zone countries Cyprus, Greece, Ireland, Portugal and Spain from 2010-2012; and Europe’s permanent rescue agency, the European Stability Mechanism, which launched in 2012. Both are based in Kirchberg.

OMT could begin next week

“If the opinion is favorable and the conditions attached are not too restrictive, it would open the way to QE by the ECB right now,” Pierre-Henri Conac, a financial law professor at the University of Luxembourg, was quoted by Bloomberg News as saying prior to the ruling.

OMT could commence as early as next week, following the ECB board meeting on 22 January, according to the German news service DPA.

“The ECB hopes its program of buying up bonds will spur the economy and bring up inflation levels--even though the effectiveness of the channel from central bank bond-buying to stimulation of the real economy remains controversial,” said DW, a German broadcaster.

Not final ruling

A decision by a full panel of justices is expected within four to six months. ECJ judges have no obligation to follow recommendations issued by advocates general, but they agree in the majority of cases.

Following that ruling, the case will return to the German constitutional court for final adjudication.

The case is C-62/14 Gauweiler & Others.