Paperjam.lu

 Thisisbossi/Creative Commons

The corporate parent of Luxembourg-based Skype has been receiving reimbursement for the cost of complying with US government surveillance operations, a British newspaper has revealed.

Microsoft, along with other major US technology firms, has claimed payments from the National Security Agency (photo) to offset the cost of participating in the “Prism” programme, The Guardian reported on Friday, citing secret documents it received from whistleblower Edward Snowden.

The NSA provided the compensation to cover the costs of annual compliance certifications required by an October 2011 ruling from the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court, a secret US tribunal. One of the documents examined by the daily, dated December 2012, said the compliance certificates “cost millions of dollars for Prism providers” each year.

Since Skype was acquired by the US tech giant that same year, the internet telephony firm has moved much of its traffic to data centres operated by Microsoft, Delano reported in July. Previously “Skype never had your data on their servers”, an industry source explained to Delano, citing the use of peer-to-peer, or P2P, file sharing technology.

The company has said switching traffic to large data centres was done to improve service, not due to government monitoring pressure.

Microsoft “legally ordered to”

“Microsoft only complies with court orders because it is legally ordered to, not because it is reimbursed for the work,” a Microsoft spokesperson told Delano on Tuesday. He declined to state the dollar amount of the payments.

“We could have a more informed discussion of these issues if providers could share additional information, including aggregate statistics on the number of any national security orders they may receive.”

Earlier this summer, Microsoft has requested permission from the secret court to reveal more details of its participation in the US government’s electronic surveillance operations.

The spokesman also referred on Tuesday to Microsoft’s 2012 “Law Enforcement Requests Report”, published this spring, which said the firm seeks payment for “providing data and content” to “law enforcement” agencies.

The document stated that: “pursuant to the Electronic Communications Privacy Act, Microsoft is entitled to seek reimbursement for costs associated with compliance with a valid US law enforcement request. We only charge US law enforcement entities pursuant to industry rates and only in an attempt to recover some costs associated with the need to comply with US legal demands. We do not, however, charge in emergency situations or in known child exploitation investigations.”

“Not part of programme”

In addition to Microsoft, The Guardian said Facebook, Google and Yahoo were among the companies that received NSA payments.

However, the social networking site denied participating in the scheme.

“Facebook has never received any compensation in connection with responding to a government data request,” a company spokeswoman told Delano on Tuesday. “We are not and have never been part of any programme to give the US or any other government direct access to servers, and as we have said repeatedly, we had never even heard of the so-called ‘Prism’ programme until it was first reported by news media.”

“We think the continued misreporting on this matter by The Guardian and others is troubling,” the Facebook spokeswoman added.

A spokeswoman for Google also stated on Tuesday that media claims were exaggerated: “We have not joined Prism or any government surveillance programmes. We do not provide any government with access to our systems and we provide user data to governments only in accordance with the law.”

“We await the US government’s response to our petition to publish more national security request data, which will show that our compliance with American national security laws falls far short of the wild claims still being made in the press today,” the Google spokeswoman said.

A Yahoo spokeswoman said the firm had no comment “beyond what we’ve already shared with The Guardian”. In its article last week, the British paper cited a Yahoo spokesperson as saying: “Federal law requires the US government to reimburse providers for costs incurred to respond to compulsory legal process imposed by the government. We have requested reimbursement consistent with this law.”

“We don’t have any information to provide for your article,” a spokeswoman for the NSA said on Tuesday.