In the summer of 2009, László Sólyom, president of Hungary, had planned to attend a local association’s unveiling of a statue of St. Stephen--Hungary’s founder and first king--in Komárno, Slovakia (photo). The date, August 21, “is considered to be a sensitive date in Slovakia” as it was on that day in 1968 that Warsaw Pact troops--including Hungary’s--invaded Czechoslovakia, according to court documents.
Following diplomatic discussions, Slovakia informed the Hungarian ambassador that Sólyom was “prohibited” from entering Slovak territory on the 21st, which the president did not attempt to do.
However, Hungary’s government complained to the European Commission that the Slovak decision violated Sólyom’s freedom of movement within the EU. The commission disagreed and did not take action, prompting Budapest to file its own case against Bratislava before the European Court of Justice in Kirchberg. Brussels supported the Slovak Republic in the case.
On Tuesday the ECJ said Slovakia’s decision was legal.
Although the president of Hungary is indeed an EU national, “the status of head of state [has] a specific character, resulting from the fact that it is governed by international law,” the court observed, citing, for example, diplomatic and security considerations.
Therefore it is reasonable to differentiate between “the person who enjoys that status from all other EU citizens, with the result that that person’s access to the territory of another member state is not subject to the same conditions as those applicable to other citizens.”
“The court dismisses Hungary’s action in its entirety,” the judges ruled.
The case was highly unusual in that the ECJ generally issues opinions for courts in member states to implement and rarely hears disputes between states. In fact, the court said that “this is only the sixth time, in the history of European integration, that one member state has directly brought infringement proceedings against another state,” and two of those matters were dropped before trial.
The case is number C-364/10 (Hungary v Slovakia).
