Maciej Szpunar delivering an opinion in 2014
 European Commission (archives)

Maciej Szpunar delivering an opinion in 2014  European Commission (archives)

Third country nationals cannot be fined for failing to pass integration exams, an advisor at the EU’s top court has counseled.

Levying financial penalties against long term residents who do not complete language and national knowledge courses is “disproportionate”, according to a preliminary opinion by Maciej Szpunar, an advocate general at the European Court of Justice in Kirchberg.

The case, according to court documents, stems from an American national, “P”, who has lived in the Netherlands since 2002 and obtained long-term resident status in 2008; and from a New Zealand national, “S”, who has lived in the Netherlands since 2000 and obtained long-term resident status in 2007. Both were cited by authorities, after being granted their long term residency, for not passing the integration examinations mandated under Dutch law.

Both then argued that as they already were permanent residents the integration requirements did not apply to them.

A Dutch administrative court asked the ECJ if such fines were consistent with European rules.

“Must facilitate integration”

On Wednesday the advocate general said they were not.

While requiring third country nationals to take integration classes is clearly allowed under a European directive, Szpunar said: “Such measures must, however, have the exclusive purpose of facilitating the integration of the person concerned and must not constitute a condition for the maintenance of that status or for the exercise of the rights which flow from it. In particular, those measures may not include any obligation to pass an examination relating to social integration.”

Local authorities should examine each person’s situation individually, he advised.

A full panel of ECJ judges will now consider that matter and issue a final ruling after several months’ time. The judges are not obliged to follow the advocate general’s recommendation, but in the majority of cases they reach the same conclusion.

The case is number C-579/13 (P & S v Commissie Sociale Zekerheid Breda, College van Burgemeester en Wethouders van de gemeente Amstelveen).