European arrest warrants, established by the EU in 2002, allow authorities in one member state to recognise orders issued by a court in another member state in a more standardised and timely manner. The system was used last month to detain a 30 year old British school teacher--who absconded with one of his 15 year old students--in Bordeaux, France, and is the protocol being used by Sweden’s government which has led Wikileaks founder Julian Assange to seek shelter in Ecuador’s embassy in London.
The case currently before the European Court of Justice was brought by Stefano Melloni, who was arrested in Spain in 1996 and ordered to stand trial in Italy. Melloni fled after posting bail with a Madrid court. In 2003 he “was sentenced, in his absence, to 10 years’ imprisonment for bankruptcy fraud,” by an Italian court, according to ECJ documents. His lawyers’ 2004 appeal was rejected by Italy’s Supreme Court of Cassation.
Spanish police re-arrested Melloni in 2008 and Spain’s Audiencia Nacional ordered him to be returned to Italy to serve his sentence.
Melloni appealed, saying he had dismissed his Italian lawyers and therefore was not properly represented before the Italian courts, and would only agree to be returned to Italy if his appeal was re-instated, which would be the case under domestic Spanish law. The appeal has worked its way up to Spain’s constitutional court, which asked the ECJ if the Spanish rulings went against the EU human rights law.
On Tuesday, Yves Bot, one of eight ECJ advocates general, said Spain had been acting within European rules.
Bot pointed out that the demand for a re-trial was a situation which the EU agreement explicitly tried to prevent, as the point of the European arrest warrant is to facilitate mutual recognition of judicial decisions.
In fact, the EU framework specifically prohibits courts in the country where a suspect is arrested “from making the execution of a European arrest warrant conditional upon the person who is the subject of the warrant being entitled to a retrial in the issuing member state,” Bot wrote in his opinion.
In addition, Melloni was aware of his trial date and there was no proof that he had officially fired his legal representation. Therefore he cannot claim that he did not receive a fair hearing from the Italian courts, the ECJ jurist said.
The case now goes before a panel of judges for an independent review of the matter. Although Bot’s decision is not binding on the court, in the majority of cases ECJ judges reach the same conclusion as advocates general.
The case is number C-399/11 (Melloni).
