Paperjam.lu

 Olivier Minaire (archives)

A new European institution is getting started in Luxembourg. The Court of Appeal of the new Unified Patent Court, the UPC, could begin operations as early as next year, if the European Patent Office has its way.

On January 11, an agreement was finalised and published by the European council of ministers that establishes a new “unified patent” across most of the EU, and a new court system to deal with legal disputes that arise from the new intellectual property regime.

Under the current system, inventors can either file national patent applications or receive a patent from the European Patent Office, which is then transformed into a series of national patents, explains Pierre Kihn, head of intellectual property law firm Office Freylinger (photo).

Negotiations over the new system started in the early 1970s, and will essentially allow inventors to file a single registration for their patents and receive protection across 25 European countries in one go.

“It is difficult to get something good out of negotiations that last 30 years,” comments Kihn. But ultimately, the new system “is a good thing for Luxembourg and for Europe that we finally have something” despite it not covering the whole EU.

Italy and Spain have refused to participate in the new scheme. Indeed the two have tried to block it before the European Court of Justice in Kirchberg, although they lost the first, but not final, step of the process in December.

“The UPC will start operations once the agreement on a UPC will have been ratified by at least 13 member states, including France, Germany and the United Kingdom,” Eskil Waage of the European Patent Office in Munich tells Delano. “The--ambitious--declared aim, to which we stick, is that this should take place by mid-2014.”

The UPC’s appeals court will be based in the Grand Duchy and “will hear appeals against decisions of the UPC’s court of first instance”, which will be comprised of tribunals in London, Munich and Paris--each specialised on different areas of intellectual property law.

Waage explains that “appeals may be lodged not only against final decisions” of the specialised courts “but also against orders or ‘intermediate’ decisions.” So the patent appeals court is likely to receive its first cases in short order. “It will not take years before the first appeal cases reach the court of appeal”, he reckons.

The appeal court will have ten judges, but Luxembourg will also be home to the UPC’s registry, which is responsible for “large number of practical-administrative issues relating to the functioning of the UPC” across the system.

Waage says “it is pure guess-work to try to predict more precisely how many cases” the appeals court will hear annually and how large its staff and budget will end up representing. Those details will be hammered out in “preparatory committee” meetings set to take place after the 13 signatures is reached.

This article originally appeared in the February 2013 print edition of Delano. As of this writing, 24 member states--not including Italy, Spain and Poland--have signed the agreement on a Unitary Patent Court, although none have ratified the deal yet; and on April 16 Italy and Spain lost their case before the European Court of Justice.