Utilising successive short-term contracts, equivalent to the contrat à durée déterminée in Luxembourg, does not necessarily constitute abuse or entitle the employee to a permanent contract, the court ruled.
The case was originally filed in a German labour court by Bianca Kücük, who “successively and without interruption over a period of 11 years” had 13 different fixed-term contracts working as a court clerk in Köln, according to the court’s press summary.
Kücük replaced several clerks when they were absent for extended periods of time, such as for parental leave. She had argued the long-term and back-to-back nature of her position meant that she was essentially being denied an indeterminate contract.
“The mere fact that an employer may have to employ temporary replacements on a recurring, or even permanent, basis and that those replacements may also be covered by the hiring of employees under employment contracts of indefinite duration does not mean that… there is abuse,” the court explained.
The court’s opinion now goes to Germany’s federal labour court for a final ruling. The case is number C-586/10.
More on the European Court of Justice in the February print edition of Delano, due out next Thursday.
