The Grand Duchy was the 8th most observant EU member state in 2013, the European Commission has said.
Brussels brought Luxembourg to book a total of 32 times last year, according to “The 31st annual report on monitoring the application of EU law” (PDF) released on Wednesday. That compares to 104 cases against Italy, 90 against Spain and 79 against Greece.
Timely transposition
“The commission monitors whether member states respect EU law obligations, i.e., completely and correctly transpose EU directives and properly apply the entire EU acquis,” meaning the entire accumulation of European rules, the report explained.
The commission said there were 74 new EU directives with a transposition deadline in 2013, and that member states missed the deadline 478 times last year.
Directives are European standards that each member state incorporates into its own national law and enforces in its own territory.
As of 31 December 2013, Luxembourg was tied with Ireland and Portugal as the 15th most frequent offender out of the EU28, with 12 late transposition cases each.
That was between France and Spain (13 each), and Bulgaria, Germany and Slovakia (11 each). The most number of late transposition infringements were recorded against Cyprus (27), Slovenia (26) and Italy (24), while the least were recorded against the Czech Republic, Greece, Montenegro and Sweden (7 each) and Croatia (2).
“Bad application”
The commission also checks complaints of “incorrect transposition or bad application of EU law”. It did so 761 times last year.
The top three subjects of these procedures were Italy (58), France (44) and Spain (41). Luxembourg had 20. The most EU-law-abiding countries were Montenegro (14 cases), Latvia (12) and Croatia (zero).
If a problem is not resolved with the member state, then Brussels can “launch infringement procedures”, which potentially leads to a trial at the European Court of Justice in Kirchberg and financial penalties for the national government.
The ECJ heard five such cases last year, dismissing one against Germany but awarding the commission fines against Belgium, the Czech Republic, Sweden and Luxembourg. The Grand Duchy had to pay €2 million for not complying with an EU directive on the treatment of urban waste water.
Nonetheless the commission report concluded that: “The Czech Republic and Portugal have managed to halve the number of their infringement cases during this period and the Netherlands and Luxembourg have also significantly improved their results. Slovenia, Cyprus and Romania saw their number of infringement cases rise over the past five years, although their total cases are at average level.”
