Fiat 500s parked in Remich, May 2009
 Flickr user Brian Snelson (CC BY 2.0)

Fiat 500s parked in Remich, May 2009  Flickr user Brian Snelson (CC BY 2.0)

Luxembourg’s finance ministry has said it “disagrees with” an EU ruling that the Grand Duchy should collect €20m-€30m in back taxes from Italy’s largest carmaker.

On Wednesday morning the European Commission said that Luxembourg’s favourable tax treatment of a Fiat unit constituted illegal state aid.

“Luxembourg will use appropriate due diligence to analyse the decision of the commission as well as its legal rationale,” the ministry said in a statement issued shortly after the commission announcement in Brussels. “Luxembourg already notes that the European Commission has used unprecedented criteria in establishing the alleged state aid.”

The commission did not prove that Fiat Finance and Trade “received selective advantages” from Luxembourg tax authorities and the commission did not properly apply EU rules in this case, the finance ministry stated. “Luxembourg adheres to international standards, in particular those relating to the arm’s length principle applicable with respect to transfer pricing, and with state aid rules.”

The commission began investigating tax treatment by Luxembourg and other EU member states in the wake of the so-called LuxLeaks affair, where confidential tax rulings were published by the International Consortium of Investigative Journalists.