Paperjam.lu

 

A US travel and lifestyle website may want to take heed of the phrase “lies, damn lies and statistics”, popularised by Mark Twain.

In a listicle entitled “What every European country is the worst at”, published last year, Thrillist said the Grand Duchy had the “lowest educational spending” in Europe. “In 2007 Luxembourg spent only 3.15% of its GDP to fund public education. Presumably, the rest of its GDP was spent adding more vowels to the country’s name.”

Thrillest included a link to Eurostat, the EU’s official statistics agency, which did not work on Thursday. Delano did find the figures on the Eurostat site, and indeed Luxembourg ranks dead last in that table. Its public education rate appeared to be half that of Belgium, Cyprus, Denmark, Finland, Ireland and Malta, for example.

Data comparisons

Except there are two, equally meaningful, problems with the Thrillist conclusion.

First, the website missed an important footnote. “The data for Luxembourg excludes the tertiary education sector” whereas figures for the 26 other EU countries included such spending (Croatia, which joined the EU in 2013, was not included in the report cited by Thrillest). Adding the University of Luxembourg’s budget, for instance, would boost the Grand Duchy’s ratio by around 0.3% of GDP alone. Plus private education was not represented in the headline figure.

Second, cross-border commuters have long represented a large part of the Grand Duchy’s workforce (43.8% at the end of 2007 and 44.3% of total workers at the end of last year, said Statec), which skews many statistical indicators. In other words, four of ten workers contribute to GDP in Luxembourg, but do not send their children to school here.

In its own international comparison of public spending, the National Center for Education Statistics, a US government agency, specifically excluded the Grand Duchy “because of anomalies in that country’s GDP per capita data”.

“Luxembourg devotes the highest level of resources to education among OECD countries in terms of spending per student,” nearly three times the OECD average, according to the policy group of wealthier countries [PDF].

European lowlights

Among the other “worsts” in Europe, Thrillist said Belgian had the “worst traffic”, France had the “lowest English proficiency”, Germany had the “lowest home ownership rate”, Italy had the “most tax evasion”, the Netherlands had the “most cyclist deaths among road accident fatalities”, Portugal had “lowest birth rate”, Spain had the “highest dropout rate”, and the UK had the “most cocaine use”.