The headline of a 22 April 2014 New York Times article, “The American Middle Class Is No Longer the World’s Richest”, explained that middle income households in the US were no longer wealthier than those in Europe and Canada. How did researchers know? Data from the Luxembourg Income Study, an independent research centre with offices on the University of Luxembourg’s Belval campus and at the Graduate Center of the City University of New York.
Comparing socioeconomic data is not always easy, since the information is often collected by national agencies using differing methods. Having comparable data, at first for one specific study, was the brainstorm of researchers from Luxembourg, Sweden and the US in the early 1980s. “Basically what they started as a project is still living after 30 years,” explains Thierry Kruten, the centre’s operations director in Luxembourg. “It started with data coming from seven countries; we have data from 55-something countries now.”
LIS collects data from national sources (primarily official statistical agencies such as Statec in Luxembourg) then standardises the figures and loads them into a special IT system, says Kruten. Researchers send in their queries for the LIS to process, since they cannot download individual datasets, which contain highly personal details.
The data covers demographic details like the age and marital status of household members, but also things like how long they have held the job and how much they make. “We have a very detailed level of income information,” including wages, benefits and taxes, “so we can really get an idea of what is the household income” in each country. That in turn sheds light on questions of inequality and social inclusion.
Other archives measure household wealth. “Someone with exactly the same income could have a totally different situation regarding his wealth situation. This is the type of data that we’re collecting, harmonising and putting at the disposal of the research community.”
About 1,300 researchers regularly used LIS data last year, reports Kruten, all of them from academic institutions or international bodies like the International Labor Organization, International Monetary Fund, OECD and World Bank (but no commercial outfits). Those institutions are also the sources of LIS’s funding (along with 20% coming from the Luxembourg government), which guarantees the centre’s independence, he reckons.
Academics usually look at several sources of data for their studies, so there is not a signature LIS paper to point to, but Kruten is proud that “we have a lot of famous researchers who work with our data”. In fact, “Paul Krugman has moved from Princeton to CUNY to join the LIS centre” referring to the 2009 Nobel prize winner in economics.
Traditionally LIS has been run by one director, a CUNY professor, but that will change when Daniele Checchi, an Italian economist, arrives in September as the new head of LIS in Luxembourg. The outfit has simply grown too much for one chief to run both locations.
