“Even when you know you are making mistakes it is hard to do something about it,” Paul Craven of the behavioural finance consultancy Salomon Partners told the Association of the Luxembourg Fund Industry spring conference on Wednesday.
We are prone to acting instinctively and emotionally, but we often believe we are being rational. Becoming aware of this common pitfall is just the first step to seeing through the natural psychological biases, which, among other things, cause irrational investment bubbles.
Please behave
We are 100% rational; at least that’s the assumption behind classical economics textbooks. But we all know that we have all spent money in illogical ways and will probably do so again. Craven pointed out that so called “sophisticated” investors are no different, with decisions worth many millions being often being poorly thought-through.
Behaviourism is a 100 year old psychological approach that deals with the way people act, not the way we think the mind should operate. Finally, these ideas are filtering through to how we understand economics and finance. “These ideas are becoming mainstream,” noted Craven. “They affect all areas of business--compliance, sales, marketing and distribution as well as investment.”
Yes, but I know I’m right
We are very influenced by human stories. Craven quoted a psychological test whereby two groups were given scientifically reliable information about new medication. They were also told stories about the experience of two people who had taken the treatment. A drug with only a 30% success rate but accompanied by a positive story of an individual making a full recovery resulted in 78% saying they would recommend that treatment. Yet, when the anecdote was negative, the same drug received the backing of only 7%. The clear scientific evidence was largely ignored in favour of random but more human information.
“We would rather believe a story than cold scientific evidence because that is an instinctive natural reaction,” argued Craven.
He demonstrated another example is how we instinctively make the wrong choices. When opening a banana, we were always taught to pull at stalk. This seems logical and natural but it is much more fiddly and messy than the correct way: gently pinching the brown stub at the very bottom of the fruit twice on all four sides. (Click on the image above to see the video of how to open a banana on YouTube.)
The same errors of blind faith in our gut instincts were contributors to the dotcom boom/bust and the 2008 sub prime crisis. They also lead to headlines such as “The Death of Equities” being emblazoned across the cover of Businessweek magazine in 1979... just before the Dow Jones started a two decade long upward trend. People find it hard to see the reality behind the mass of information we receive, so we use emotion and “intuition” instead.
“In every important discussion you need someone to play devil’s advocate to provoke creative, non-standard thinking,” Craven told the Alfi audience. “Jumping to early conclusions can mislead.”