Aside from the fact that the target was not a government agency, the public may never know which Luxembourg organisation was allegedly hacked by China’s army.
On Tuesday the US electronic security company Mandiant announced that an unnamed organisation in Luxembourg was among 141 victims of a “cyber espionage unit” named “APT1” which Mandiant claimed is affiliated with the Chinese military.
China’s government has strenuously denied the allegations, telling the Washington Post that “the accusation that the Chinese military engaged in cyberattacks is neither professional nor in accordance with facts.”
In its report, the security firm did not reveal the name any organisations whose IT systems it said had been systematically breached over the past seven years “due to the privacy concerns of those impacted”, a spokeswoman for Mandiant told Delano.
“The attacks mentioned in Mandiant’s APT1 report did not compromise either IT or communication systems of the Luxembourgish Government” which “was indeed not victim of the attack”, a spokesman for the state’s Computer Emergency Response Team confirmed on Wednesday.
The agency is responsible for cyberattacks against government agencies and infrastructure operators in Luxembourg, although not for IT networks at companies, EU institutions, NGOs and private citizens.
The “type of attack” mentioned in Mandiant’s report “is in no way to be considered out of the ordinary,” the government spokesman said. “In fact among others, governments are regularly facing IT intrusion attempts” and “Luxembourg is no exception to this”.
He said that it was “no surprise” that “Luxembourg figures in such types of reports, although the victim is not governmental.”
Unwanted attention
Indeed, the identity of the victim may never be known as there is no legal requirement to disclose such attacks, explained Ralf-Philipp Weinmann, a computer security researcher at the University of Luxembourg.
Weinmann, who does not have first-hand knowledge of the attacks described in Mandiant’s report, said “there’s no obligation to alert national authorities of such attacks, so many organisations often engage” a private “incident response team for pay instead of bringing in the national CERTs” in order to avoid unwanted attention.
That could change, Weinmann noted. The European Commission, Germany and the US all “are trying to pass legislation to make reporting of attacks mandatory to get more synergy in detecting and countering campaigns”, although the move is currently being blocked by the UK at the EU level.
The University of Luxembourg researcher said he was “not endorsing these mandatory reporting requirements” or opposing them.
The CERT spokesman did not state if Luxembourg’s government had a position on the proposal.
