America’s second largest political party has taken a move against tax evasion rules that are unpopular in Luxembourg. The Republican National Committee adopted a resolution to repeal FATCA on Friday.
The resolution passed “overwhelmingly”, Solomon Yue, Jr. of the Oregon Republican Party, who authored the resolution, told Delano on Monday.
The Republican Party, also known as the “Grand Old Party”, currently holds a slim majority in the lower house of the US congress, although all 435 seats will be contested this November. The upper house and White House are held by Barack Obama’s Democratic Party.
“To repeal FATCA, the GOP must win both houses in November with a super majority in 2014,” said Yue, who represents Oregon Republicans on the party’s national committee, which held a national conference in Washington last week. “Otherwise, President Obama could veto the repeal legislation.”
Yue hopes the measure will equally be adopted as part of the party’s 2016 presidential election platform, he told Delano.
He commented that: “FATCA is modern day Sophie’s Choice. Overseas US citizens are forced to choose between their love for their country by not renouncing citizenship and welfare of their families by providing for them.”
“We are pushing for a full repeal as well as restoration of citizenship to those Americans who had to give it up because of FATCA’s negative impact on their families’ livelihood.”
“Dragnet approach”
FATCA has been a source of concern for the Grand Duchy’s financial sector since the law was passed in 2010, with many in the industry arguing it imposes unreasonable costs on firms and breaches EU and Luxembourg privacy laws. The law requires nearly every financial institution in the world to provide information to the IRS, the US tax office, on anyone with links with the US.
“They are using the same dragnet approach in the NSA’s data collection case,” Yue said. “Did we catch the Boston bombers? No.”
The Republican leader also critiqued the “FATCA partnership” agreements the US signed with several countries--including France, Germany, Japan, Switzerland and the UK--that allows data to be handled via national agencies, instead of financial institutions submitting files directly to the IRS.
Luxembourg is currently negotiating such a deal, although officials in both the US and the Grand Duchy would not comment on the status of those talks.
“We believe the reciprocity feature of FATCA through intergovernmental agreements really is a data collection operation on both overseas US citizens and foreign citizens residing in the US. We should be very concerned because it takes away constitutional protection of those citizens’ right to privacy,” Yue said.
“Urgent need”
A spokesman for Democrats Abroad Luxembourg told Delano that the group “recognises the urgent need to provide relief to Americans living abroad with respect to FATCA”. He said the global organisation formed a task force in 2011 with an aim to “lessen [the law’s] unintended adverse impacts on Americans living abroad”.
The task force has proposed several reforms that would lighten reporting requirements for both US citizens and international financial institutions, he stated on Monday. Among other measures, “members of that task force have testified before congress” and “lobbied lawmakers in Washington”.
“We Americans living abroad now find our financial lives exposed to a degree of scrutiny--under threat of severe penalties, fines and even imprisonment--to which Americans living stateside are not subjected. Implicit in this stringent reporting regulation is the unfair and unjustified suspicion that Americans living abroad are tax cheats and/or money launderers, which clearly the vast majority are not,” the Democratic spokesman said.
American officials have defended the law and said the July 1 implementation date will not be pushed back. “FATCA continues to gain momentum and international support as we work with partners around the world to fight offshore tax evasion,” a US treasury department official told Delano last week.
UPDATED: An earlier version of this article neglected to cite sources when it stated that the GOP is the second largest American political party. That was reported in a 2011 USA Today study, a 2012 Pew Research Center study, and the most recent Gallup poll, taken January 5-8, 2014, which found 29% of respondents identified as Democrats and 24% as Republicans.
