The European Court of Justice broke up the European Commission fine
 Flickr user GabPRR/Creative Commons (2012)

The European Court of Justice broke up the European Commission fine  Flickr user GabPRR/Creative Commons (2012)

The EU’s top court has reduced an anti-trust fine against Guardian Industries by 30%, saying intra-group sales should have been taken into account.

The case stemmed from a European Commission investigation that in 2007 found four firms had engaged in a price fixing cartel in the European flat glass market, according to a court summary. The commission, the EU’s anti-trust agency, then fined Guardian €148 million.

The company contested the penalty at the European General Court in Luxembourg, which upheld the commission’s decision in September 2012. Guardian then appealed to the European Court of Justice, which is located in the same Kirchberg judicial complex.

On Wednesday, the ECJ cut the fine down to €103.6 million, noting that the commission had excluded sales within the same corporate family from its penalty calculations. That “led to the relative weight of [French glass maker] Saint-Gobain (a vertically integrated company) in the infringement in particular being reduced and that of Guardian (a non-vertically integrated company) being increased commensurately,” the court said.

A spokesman for the commission said the ruling only annulled part of the General Court’s earlier decision. “The commission will carefully analyse the judgment and its implications. In particular, the judgment raises important questions about the level of antitrust fines that can be imposed on vertically and non-vertically integrated companies,” Ricardo Cardoso told Delano via email.

A spokeswoman for Guardian told Delano that it had “no comment at this time”.

On its website, Guardian said it is one of the world’s largest makers of glass products in the world and is a major supplier in the automotive and construction sectors. The company is based in the US with its European headquarters in Luxembourg.

As of 1 January of this year, the Guardian group employed approximately 1,280 staff at its complex in Dudelange, making it the 23rd largest non-state employer in the Grand Duchy, according to the official statistics agency Statec.

The ECJ case was number C-580/12 P (Guardian Industries Corporation and Guardian Europe Sàrl v Commission).