Paperjam.lu

 Oliver Minaire (archives)

Luxembourg’s treatment of cross-border workers’ children seeking financial aid goes “beyond what is necessary to attain its objective”, the EU’s top court has ruled.

The Grand Duchy’s government has a stated goal of increasing the number of residents with a higher education degree, and to encourage them to come back after that degree was achieved to integrate into Luxembourg’s labour market. In order to attain this objective, the state has been granting financial aid to its residents’ children to attend university.

Although the EU law states that migrant workers must benefit from the same social advantages as local employees, Luxembourg has been denying grants of financial aid to cross-border workers’ children.

Several non-resident parents and students--including Elodie Giersch, who had applied for aid to attend the University of Luxembourg--had brought a case before the Grand Duchy’s Tribunal Administratif, which then asked the European Court of Justice in Kirchberg if “the Luxembourg legislation relating to the grant of that aid is compatible with the principle of the freedom of movement of workers.”

On Thursday, the court held that “the residence condition required by Luxembourg legislation amounts to indirect discrimination on grounds of nationality in so far as it is liable to operate mainly to the detriment of nationals of other member states, as non-residents are in the majority of cases foreign nationals”.

Moreover, the judges said the restrictions applying to migrant and cross-border workers were “discriminating” as a person’s attachment to Luxembourg does not necessarily relate with residing there. The restraints were therefore not justified.

However, the ECJ validated the policy goal itself, admitting that “the condition of residence is appropriate for attaining the objective pursued by Luxembourg of promoting higher education studies and of significantly increasing the proportion of Luxembourg residents who hold a higher education degree”.

“The system of financial aid in question is too exclusive in nature”

Ruling the policy goes against the freedom of movement for workers, the court said Luxembourg must adapt a system that meets it educational target while granting financial aid to cross-border workers’ children.

Therefore, the court offered different compromises which consist in granting the financial aid under more severe conditions than to a national worker: “the financial aid could be made conditional on that parent having worked in Luxembourg for a certain minimum period of time.”

The court also suggested the government could make loans available for students to study outside of Luxembourg, with beneficial repayment terms for those who return to work and live in the Grand Duchy.

The matter now goes back to the Tribunal Administratif for final adjudication.

The case was C-20/12 (Elodie Giersch and Others v Luxembourg).