One of the three main global credit ratings agencies has re-iterated its top-notch score on the Grand Duchy’s debt. As part of its annual ratings review, Moody’s Investors Service said “Luxembourg’s AAA government bond rating… remains supported by the country’s position as one of the wealthiest countries in the world as well as its solid growth track record.”
AAA is the highest score on the firm’s 21-level scale. The Grand Duchy is one of only five euro area countries--along with Austria, Finland, Germany and the Netherlands--with AAA Moody’s ratings. The sole non-euro EU member state with an AAA Moody’s rating is Sweden. Switzerland also has the firm’s top score.
“Luxembourg’s creditworthiness is primarily based on its solid growth track record and robust wealth levels, as reflected by its GDP per capita, which, even when adjusted for cross-border workers, is one of the highest in the world,” the agency said on Tuesday.
Moody’s credited the government’s “continuation of proactive policy” in the development of the financial sector, noting that “the regulatory authorities’ prudential supervision and rigorous controls of financial entities are supporting rating factors.” The ratings agency also signalled the “soundness” of the country’s banking system and “the financial sector’s high degree of compartmentalisation, which limits its susceptibility to systemic shock”.
Government debt levels
In addition, the credit bureau cited “the preservation of the government’s robust balance sheet” as a plus. Moody’s said its “assessment is supported by the still low level of debt (although it has tripled [to] 20.8% of GDP in 2012 from 2007 levels), as well as the significant amount of assets accumulated under the country’s pension system (28.5% of GDP).”
Luxembourg government debt rose about 10% in the first quarter, to just over €10 billion, but remains the third lowest level in the EU, according to figures released earlier this month by official statistics service Eurostat. That compared with just over €9 billion during the first quarter of 2012.
The Grand Duchy had the third lowest level of government debt and deficit spending in Europe last year. Luxembourg’s government deficit represented -0.8% of the country’s GDP in 2012, an increase four-fold from -0.2% in 2011, Eurostat said in April.
Negative outlook
At the same time, Moody’s attached a “negative outlook” to its report, meaning it believes there is a chance the rating could be lowered within the next year or so.
In addition to “uncertainty regarding the outcome of the euro area debt crisis”, the agency observed that Luxembourg is heavily reliant on the financial services sector for economic growth, jobs and tax revenues. The financial industry “is under pressure from, among other factors, the evolving regulatory and tax frameworks in the EU”.
Moody’s also estimated Luxembourg’s treasury will lose 1.4% of GDP in tax revenues after VAT collection is harmonised under EU rules in 2015.
Rival ratings agency Standard & Poor’s affirmed Luxembourg’s top-notch AAA credit score in January, while last September Fitch Ratings affirmed the Grand Duchy’s AAA score. Both gave Luxembourg a “stable outlook”, meaning the two agencies did not anticipate lowering the rating within the following 12 to 18 months.
A lower credit score typically leads to higher borrowing costs in the capital markets.
So far this year, the Grand Duchy has sold at least €2.75 billion in bonds, paying interest rates lower than the governments of France, the UK and US, but higher than those of Japan, Germany and Sweden.
