Paperjam.lu

 Olivier Minaire (archives)

The financial transaction tax is “the single most important threat to the financial sector in general and to the fund industry in particular,” a panellist at a conference organised by the Association of the Luxembourg Fund Industry has said.

It “will be imposed on financial transactions and that’s the core business of an investment fund,” Nenad Ilic, senior tax specialist at ING Investment Management in Luxembourg, told Alfi’s 25th spring conference on Tuesday. “It will not be imposed only once on investment funds, it will be imposed multiple times.”

The FTT is currently in the process of being adapted by 11 European countries, not including the Grand Duchy, with the aim of dampening risky financial engineering and providing a safety reserve for the financial sector and struggling government budgets.

Despite not joining the group of 11, the tax will touch Luxembourg. During a panel discussion on regulations, Ilic noted that “whenever there is at least one party or intermediary to any given transaction that is resident in the FTT zone, the transaction becomes taxable and all parties to that transaction have to pay the tax.” The tax is also due “on securities issued by a resident of the FTT zone”, which includes Belgium, France, Germany, Italy and Spain.

Duties will rapidly mount for fund-of-fund and master-feeder fund structures, as well as for electronically traded funds, the Alfi panellists agreed, because each step in processing a client’s operation is considered a separate transaction. “If you manage a money market fund, what is going to be the return for the investor?” Gilles Dauphiné, head of solutions strategists at a unit of AXA in Paris, rhetorically asked.

In the end “it’s not possible to not be part of the FTT [zone] to a certain extent”, in view of panel moderator Georges Bock (photo, right), managing partner of KPMG in Luxembourg.

Investors, managers need to take notice

“Investors need to be aware that [they will be] the one who’s going to pay it,” argued Manfred Bauer, head of product management at a unit of DWS Investment in Luxembourg. “Many people are thinking that is something that it’s going to be paid by financial institutions… but in the end it’s their money.”

The FTT “certainly will have a negative impact” on Luxembourg’s fund centre, Ilic commented. “However, it will have the same impact for all other non-FTT countries. So from that point of view, we’re not worse off than other fund jurisdictions.”

Speaking to Delano after the panel discussion, Jean-Christian Six, a partner at Allen & Overy in Luxembourg, said many of his clients had yet to fully appreciate the impact of the FTT. “It’s probably lost somewhere in the avalanche of regulations and tax rules. I think that a number of players in Luxembourg believe that because Luxembourg would not be a part of this new regulation, we would be completely shielded from, or not be impacted at all, by the new regulation,” he said on the side-lines of the conference. “It might not be as easy as that”.

The FTT could come into effect as soon as January 1, although the final agreement has not yet been reached.