Paperjam.lu

 European Parliament (archives)

The geographic reach of the proposed European financial transaction tax is likely to be revisited, but some sort of FTT is still likely to be introduced, a risk consultancy has said.

“Questions about the legality and extraterritorial implications of the EU 11 FTT are increasingly leading EU policy-makers to re-consider the feasibility of the current proposal,” according to a report issued Wednesday by Eurasia Group.

The FTT is a planned levy on the transfer of stocks, bonds and other instruments that aims to dampen speculative financial activity. Sometimes called a “Tobin Tax”, it is forecast by the European Commission to raise between €30 billion and €35 billion for the EU 11 countries that are planning to implement the fee. However the current draft calls for the tax to be collected from all parties located outside the FTT zone if at least one counterparty is based inside one of the 11 nations.

Questions raised

The European Council’s legal service wrote in an internal opinion for finance ministers leaked this week that the proposal “is discriminatory”, exceeds member states’ jurisdictions, and is contrary to EU law.

The UK, supported by Luxembourg, is currently challenging the tax at the European Court of Justice in Kirchberg. In addition, the political research firm pointed out “that the German constitution prohibits levying non-enforceable taxes--and there are serious concerns that the EU may not be able to collect the FTT from parties outside its jurisdiction.”

The European Commission has disputed the conclusions and significance of legal advisors’ memo. A spokeswoman for Algirdas Šemeta, EU tax commissioner, told Delano the leaked document only addresses a limited part of the proposal and not its fundamental principles, and overall “the proposed FTT is legally sound”. The commission would nevertheless study the opinion further, she said.

“Significantly weakened”

The Eurasia Group paper, citing figures from data provider Thomson Reuters, observed that France’s “share of European equities trading has fallen 23%” since the country introduced a national FTT last year, “similar to Sweden’s experiment with a domestic transaction tax in the 1980s-1990s”.

“It is possible that the European Commission will release a new, significantly weakened draft of the FTT this year,” the Eurasia Group analysts wrote. “We still think that a significantly weakened EU 11 joint tax is likely to eventually be agreed upon (sometimes in the 2014-15 timeframe) given the political impetus and the high-profile nature of the policy.”

Only German withdrawal could scupper the levy’s introduction, they said.

However the report concluded that “any such tax will likely strongly resemble the UK stamp duty, while possibly also taking some elements from the French FTT. As such, it is more likely to be based on the issuance (and not on the residence) principle with possible select application to equities and some derivatives.”