EU countries will have to automatically exchange details on “tax rulings” with other member states under a plan proposed by the European Commission this week.
Tax rulings or “comfort letters” are issued by national tax offices to corporations and guarantee in advance how certain revenue will be treated.
The plan was proposed in the wake of the LuxLeaks scandal, where details on hundreds of tax rulings from Luxembourg’s tax office were published last year in several international media outlets. In the eyes of many citizens and activists the documents showed systematic tax evasion by multinational corporations. Even before LuxLeaks, the commission had already launched investigations into Luxembourg’s tax agreements with Amazon and Fiat, and those between Ireland and Apple and Starbucks and the Netherlands.
To date, there has been no evidence presented that the companies have broken any laws or regulations.
Tax Transparency Package
“Tolerance has reached rock-bottom for companies that avoid paying their fair share of taxes, and for the regimes that enable them to do this,” Pierre Moscovici, European tax commission, said in Wednesday’s announcement. “We have to rebuild the link between where companies really make their profits and where they are taxed. To do this, member states need to open up and work together. That is what today’s Tax Transparency Package aims to achieve.”
The package called for EU states to share a standard set of details on existing tax deals starting next year and provide updates each quarter. Fellow European countries could then ask for specific information “if they believe that it is relevant to their own taxation rules,” according to the commission.
“The ability of the commission to push through the plan remains uncertain,” according to the Financial Times, which cited the need for all 28 EU countries to agree to the new rules. That means that Luxembourg could potentially block the programme.
Some said the draft regulations were too weak and would not fix the problems revealed by the LuxLeaks documents. “Over 150 companies in the leak were associated with the United States, but they will simply be out of bounds under this proposal,” the AFP news agency quoted Koen Roovers of the Financial Transparency Coalition in Brussels as saying.
Reuters news agency noted that: “Moscovici said the EU wanted global exchange of tax ruling information and the issue would be raised at an IMF meeting in April.”
