In recent months, the once-hot “emerging markets” segment (which includes shares in countries like Mexico, Poland and Thailand) has cooled and talk has shifted to “frontier markets” (which includes countries like Kenya, Serbia and Vietnam) as the next big thing. But are emerging markets set to rebound and are frontier markets all that they are cracked up to be?
The Luxembourg unit of Swedish asset manager Coeli hosted a debate on just this topic between its emerging markets macro and frontier markets teams last Thursday. Following the event, two of the panellists shed some light on the debate for Delano: James Bannan, a Coeli frontier markets portfolio manager, and Coeli COO Andrew Medhurst, who was a member of the emerging markets team during the conference.
AG: For an average retail investor, what are the main differences right now between “emerging” and “frontier” markets?
James Bannan (Coeli’s frontier markets team): When we look at the attractive demographic profiles, raising levels of productivity and low levels of leverage frontier markets look a lot like the more traditional emerging markets, including China, India and Brazil, 20 years ago. One of the key differences is that while a number of the larger emerging markets, including Brazil, China and Russia, are battling with the significant structural reforms required to move from middle income to upper income, the fruit is hanging a lot lower in frontier markets, which is fantastic for growth.
Andrew Medhurst (Coeli’s emerging markets team): I see two main differences. Firstly, in general but with a few exceptions, economies are much bigger in emerging markets than in frontier markets and the total size of EM is much bigger than FM; this should be taken into account when an investor is thinking about appropriate portfolio allocations. Secondly, I believe the number of asset class alternatives is much wider in EM. A decision to invest in FM is more limited in its scope--for example, e.g. buying equities--whilst investors in EM--and particularly a macro strategy--can invest not just in equities, but very liquid FX [foreign exchange] and domestic fixed income markets. This provides a much greater opportunity to select exposures where we think opportunities are greatest whilst hedging those exposures we prefer to avoid.
AG: Is there a risk of a “frontier bubble" forming?
JB: Frontier markets are certainly gaining momentum as an investment theme and when that happens there is always the risk of a bubble forming, but I don’t see it right now. The one exception is the Middle East where valuations are really stretched as a result of the imminent upgrade of Qatar and UAE from the Frontier to the Emerging Market Index by MSCI. Excluding this region, frontier markets are trading at ten times 2014 earnings, which is far from expensive, particularly given the 4% dividend yield that you also collect on the way.
AG: How can emerging markets regain their attractiveness to investors?
AM: EM has had a difficult 12 months with developed market equities and bonds generally outperforming. It seems to us with DM stock markets at historical highs and much of the slowdown in EM economies already priced in, we could see significant rallies in 2014 in EM assets particularly if upcoming EM election outcomes increase the likelihood of structural reforms. Whilst we think some EM currencies remain overvalued, so FX may need to be hedged, it’s possible that interest rates are close to a peak and the anticipation of rate cuts will trigger rallies, particularly in domestic bonds. EM contributes 50% of world GDP but remains a small proportion of total financial assets, so a little good news can have a disproportionate effect when international investors believe assets are ‘priced right’. We think Russia and Turkey assets offer value and can outperform as can the wider EM local bond universe.
AG: What type of investor do you hope will be interested in your respective funds?
JB: The structural drivers in frontier markets--demographics, increasing productivity and low levels of debt--are going to take decades to play out. Therefore, this asset class is ideal for long term investors.
AM: Global macro is described as the ultimate ‘go anywhere’ strategy. The Coeli Global EM Macro fund will potentially offer investors performance in rising and falling markets and, we hope, something different--perhaps even complimentary--for a portfolio mainly invested in equities.
A bull market for a macro trader is typically [during an] economic slowdown when interest rates start to fall to reflect weaker demand and we think we may be entering such a period in a number of EM economies. Whilst domestic bonds could produce excellent returns, we will hedge FX where currencies are still overvalued.
In conclusion, our fund should appeal to investors who are sceptical about the current benign global investment environment and want some exposure to a strategy which should benefit from volatility and show ‘crisis alpha’. The world currently contemplates a Chinese slowdown but developed markets have limited ability to extend quantitative easing!
