The so-called “single European patent” can proceed, despite objections from Italy and Spain, the European Court of Justice ruled on Tuesday.
The “unitary patent” is meant to streamline intellectual property registration and protection, by allowing inventors to receive pan-European patents via one application, by reducing the number of languages used in official documents to English, French and German, instead of all official languages in the EU, and by establishing specialised patent courts, including an appeals court in Luxembourg. The new system is optional and does not eliminate national patents.
However, Italy and Spain did not agree to the new regime. So in 2011 the European council of government ministers struck a deal under the EU’s “enhanced cooperation” procedures, which allows nine or more member states to move ahead with an initiative, when needed “as a last resort”. Indeed all the other 25 EU countries signed on to the unitary patent accord, which was then approved by both the European Commission and the European Parliament.
Italy and Spain then asked the ECJ in Kirchberg to block the agreement, contending that intellectual property is the domain of the “internal” or single European market, and that negotiations had not run their proper course, both of which mean “enhanced cooperation” cannot be used. The side-deal “circumvented the requirement of unanimity and brushed aside those two member states’ objections to the Commission’s proposal on the language arrangements for the single European patent”, the court summarised the Italian and Spanish arguments.
On Tuesday, the ECJ rejected the two countries’ claims.
Ministers’ handling of the patent deal “by no means constitutes circumvention of the requirement of unanimity or exclusion of” Italy and Spain. Instead, having concluded it was “impossible to reach common arrangements for the whole EU within a reasonable period” the deal between the other 25 countries “contributes to the process of integration”, the judges ruled.
No “damage” to internal market
“Furthermore, contrary to what has been claimed, the contested decision does not damage the internal market or the economic, social and territorial cohesion of the EU. What is more, according to the court, the contested decision does not prejudice any competence, right or obligation of those member states not participating in this enhanced cooperation,” the court said.
The joined cases were C-274/11 and C-295/11 (Spain and Italy v Council).
The ECJ’s decision is final.
