An Amazon Kindle e-book reader
 Flickr user Johan Larsson/Creative Commons (2010)

An Amazon Kindle e-book reader  Flickr user Johan Larsson/Creative Commons (2010)

The EU’s top court has ruled that the Grand Duchy cannot charge a reduced rate of value added tax on electronic books.

Since 2012 Luxembourg has levied a VAT rate of 3% for e-books and France levied 5.5%. The European Commission took both countries to the European Court of Justice in Kirchberg 16 months ago saying the rates were too low under EU tax rules on the provision of services. That means the rate should have been at least 15%.

Luxembourg and France had argued that e-books were goods, meaning they could apply a reduced VAT rate.

On Thursday the ECJ agreed with the commission. “Only the physical support enabling an electronic book to be read could qualify as ‘tangible property’ but such support is not part of the supply of electronic books,” the judges ruled.

The ECJ judges also said that nothing prevented EU countries from setting VAT on physical books to the reduced rate of 5%.

The court decision will only change taxes for Luxembourg residents. Since the beginning of this year, under a different set of EU rules, VAT has been charged at the rate in the consumer’s country, not the seller’s. That has impacted companies such as Amazon, which use Luxembourg as a European sales hub.

The Grand Duchy’s government said it would withdraw the offending tax circular. At the same time: “Luxembourg will continue to defend [within the the EU] the principle of technological neutrality in tax matters--particularly the alignment of VAT rates between digital books and physical books--and to advocate the need to adapt the European regulatory framework to technological progress,” the culture ministry said in a statement.

According to Statista, a data provider, e-books represented 4.5% of total European book sales in 2013, a figure forecast to grow to 21% by 2017.

As of the writing representatives the European Commission and Amazon had not returned Delano’s messages seeking comment.

The cases were number C-479/13 (Commission v France) and C-502/13 (Commission v Luxembourg).