US tax reporting rules FATCA and the financial transactions tax being introduced by 11 European countries--not including the Grand Duchy--are both likely to have a huge impact on Luxembourg’s fund sector, attendees of the Association of the Luxembourg Fund Industry’s 25th spring conference heard this week. But are the Grand Duchy’s funds ready for the coming regulations?
Generally speaking, “the big ones are, the smaller ones aren’t”, Hermann Beythan (photo), an attorney with Linklaters in Luxembourg, told Delano on the side-lines of the conference.
At the same time, a new market of sorts is being created, as some of the bigger organisations are looking at how to sell their readiness to smaller competitors. “The bigger ones are probably paving the ways for the others,” according to Jean-Christian Six, an attorney with Allen & Overy in Luxembourg. With FATCA and a host of other new rules constantly coming into force, it is becoming “more and more complicated for smaller players to comply with this, what we call, ‘tsunami of regulations’. It also creates an opportunity for a number of service providers in Luxembourg to offer a range of services to assist other players,” Six said.
Yet the trend concerned Beythan, who said an expanding rulebook gives larger frims the upper hand. “Increasing regulation really pushes the markets towards the bigger ones and pushes out the smaller ones. The question is… will this not reduce competition over time and will this not lead to oligopolies?”
“Extraterritorial reach”
In Beythan’s view, proposals such as the financial transactions tax “absolutely” will hurt the fund industry. “The problem is not limited to the FTT; it’s really the issue of extraterritorial reach of regulation that creates regulatory overlap and ultimately a regulatory jungle where the stronger nations may impose their will on weaker nations. FATCA is one example, the financial transactions tax is another example [and the EU’s] AIFMD, to a certain extent, is yet another example.”
Little prevents other global powers from instituting their own versions of FATCA or an FTT, noted Sandrine Leclercq, an attorney with Baker & McKenzie in Luxembourg. “It’s all a matter of power in the negotiation. The US is probably the only one so far who is able to afford this, but tomorrow, China, that’s a good example.”
