Carlo Klein
 Annabelle Denham

Carlo Klein  Annabelle Denham

Is economics a value free “science”? This question comes up quite regularly in the economic debate and the problem can easily be illustrated with the following simple example.

This month Statec, the Grand Duchy’s official statistics bureau, published for the first time Luxembourg’s national accounts following the introduction of a new European System of National and Regional Accounts (ESA) methodology.

Research and development, financial, international and some other transactions--considered as illegal or undeclared, such as prostitution and drugs transactions--will be recorded in a more accurate way.

The expected result should be an improved estimate of our GDP, a quantitative indicator measuring the economic value created during a given period of time (often calculated each quarter and each year) by considering all economic transactions in a country.

In general, there are difficulties obtaining accurate empirical economic indicators due to the fact that not all transactions are or can be registered officially (do-it-yourself activities, black markets and illegal activities, for example). So, from the economic point of view it makes sense to try to evaluate the real value of economic transactions including, as much as possible, undeclared or illegal activities.

The result for Luxembourg should be a low but significant increase of GDP by 0.2% (and from 0% to 5% for all EU countries, according to initial estimates from Statec). The consequences of this methodological change can be considered as an example of positive economics, a value-free description of what the economy really looks like.

Now, from a normative point of view, GDP is also considered as a (flawed) indicator of economic well-being and as a tool for policy purposes (like growth rates and the ratio of public debt to GDP).

Of course, nobody will seriously suggest investments in these specific activities to boost the economy and to create jobs, but nevertheless these methodological changes show that economics and the analysis of an economy are not value-free. This had already been stated by Daniel M. Hausman and Michael S. McPherson in 1993: “Ethics determines the ends and economics defines the means.”

Making comparisons

We also have to mention that identical economic activities will be considered in different countries (or not, which is the case in the United States, for example) even if legal frameworks may differ from one country to another (from Sweden to Germany for prostitution, from the Netherlands to Luxembourg for “soft drugs”, for example).

This simple example illustrates the fact that economic analysis may either be limited to simple descriptions of an economy or be based on ethical issues and then becomes normative.

On the one hand empirical indicators should capture all economic activity whatever we think about these activities from an ethical or moral point of view. On the other hand if we use these same indicators for policy issues then I think that moral and ethical issues come into play.

This distinction is, at least in my eyes, not always made in public discussions of these concepts. By the way, there has been almost no discussion of this new method here in Luxembourg, whereas you could find public discourse in other countries.

Carlo Klein teaches economics and social sciences at the Athénée de Luxembourg and international economics at Miami University in Differdange.