Brussels has said that France and Luxembourg should charge 15% VAT on e-books immediately, even though the two countries will be forced to raise the rates by 2015 in any event. This week’s warning was the second step in infringement procedures that Brussels began in July.
Cross-border e-book sales are an emerging part of Luxembourg’s economy. To promote the sector, late last year the Grand Duchy’s government lowered the VAT from 15 to three percent on the category, which is meant to benefit e-commerce firms with European hubs in Luxembourg, such as Amazon, Apple, Barnes & Noble, Netflix and Skype. France lowered its VAT on e-books to seven percent at the same time.
However, the European Commission said on Wednesday that “e-books constitute electronically supplied services, and application of a reduced rate to this type of services is excluded.”
“This situation is creating a serious distortion of competition to the disadvantage of operators in the 25 other member states of the union, as e-books can be easily purchased in a member state other than that in which the consumer is resident,” the commission explained in a memo.
“The two member states have one month in which to bring their legislation into compliance with EU law. Otherwise, the commission may refer the matter to the European Court of Justice.”
No matter the result of these proceedings, harmonised EU-wide rates will come into effect in 2015, eliminating the advantage, Etienne Schneider, Luxembourg’s economy minister noted in a speech on Tuesday.
Although the new rules will not be finalised until 2013, VAT will change from “a VAT system based on taxation at origin” to one that is “collected in the country of destination” where the end-user is based, the commission announced last year.
Until the new system is up and running, however, Brussels is compelled to respect the letter of the law today, the commission said.
