Joaquín Almunia
 European Commission (archives)

Joaquín Almunia  European Commission (archives)

The European Commission believes that a “transfer pricing” agreement between the Grand Duchy’s tax authorities and a Luxembourg unit of Italy’s largest carmaker probably goes against European law.

Transfer pricing involves multinational corporations booking revenue and charging expenses between operations in different countries and territories.

Luxembourg’s government approved a 2012 arrangement by Fiat Finance and Trade, the internal financing arm of Fiat Group, that could amount to illegal “state aid” because the carmaker paid less tax than would be normally expected, the office of European competition commissioner Joaquín Almunia said in a 32 page memo to the Luxembourg government (PDF in French) on Tuesday. It requested more information about the deal.

Brussels also made a similar initial finding for Irish tax rulings favourable to Apple, as reported by the Financial Times. The commission is additionally investigating the Netherlands’ tax treatment of Starbucks, according to Bloomberg News.

The commission first began looking into the Fiat case in the spring. Fiat and the other firms could be liable for back taxes amounting to millions of euros, according to some estimates, however there are no financial penalties against EU member states in such cases.

No special treatment, say Luxembourg and Fiat

The Grand Duchy’s finance ministry said in a press statement on Tuesday that: “The text published contains no new elements. Luxembourg has submitted all requested information to the commission and is fully cooperating with the commission in the investigation. It is confident that the allegations of state aid in this case are unsubstantiated and that it will be able to convince the commission in due time of the legitimacy of the tax ruling concerned.”

Fiat’s press office in Turin declined to comment. However it referred Delano to an 11 June statement which said: “Tax rulings are common practice to clarify in advance the treatment of international tax matters, and it is normal practice for companies to seek such official clarifications before entering into complex transactions.”

In addition, Fiat stated that it “has no reason to believe that any favorable treatment was contemplated by the tax authorities of Luxembourg in issuing such tax ruling, because in fact no such treatment was ever received.”

After the commission’s preliminary finding letter to Luxembourg is published in the Official Journal of the European Union, “all interested parties” will have one month to respond.