Xavier Bettel (second from right) and other leaders show respect for terror attack victims during a ceremony in capital’s place de Paris on 15 November
 Christophe Olinger

Xavier Bettel (second from right) and other leaders show respect for terror attack victims during a ceremony in capital’s place de Paris on 15 November  Christophe Olinger

Call it what you will, the Patriot Act (USA 2001), the Prevention of Terrorism Act (UK 1974, amended ad infinitum) or the new act that prime minister Xavier Bettel wants to impose on Luxembourg in December, emergency measures introduced in the face of acts of wanton terrorism are more often than not a knee-jerk reaction show of strength that does little but stifle liberties.

Bettel’s new state of emergency law would allow for the extension from 24 to 48 hours the time police can hold a suspect before charges are made. The act would ban the sale of prepaid phone cards and extend communications surveillance capabilities as well as allow entrapment of enemies of the state through social media. Furthermore, if the security threat to Luxembourg reaches Level 3, the authorities will also be able to conduct searches--of home, property or person--without having to obtain a warrant.

These changes should be temporary, but history tells us this in not always the case.

The 21st century is already littered with examples, some laughably ridiculous, others worryingly brutal, that highlight precisely how open to abuse such emergency laws are. At best, innocents have been arrested and held for hours for doing nothing more than walking on a cycle path. At worst the law has allowed armed officers to shoot a man dead on public transport because he was wrongly identified as a terror suspect.

In the wake of the Paris terror attacks there is a clear need for the security forces to be fully informed and to have the ability to track people on verified suspect lists. Professional armed response teams are also a necessity, but while deploying extra police officers at potential soft target public events, such as the Bazaar International at the end of November, certainly looks like a solid preventative measure, it may just make the public more jittery as much as serve to reassure.

The most promising new measure in the prime minister’s package of proposals is the introduction of a counsellor at schools who can be approached if parents or friends think a student is in danger of becoming radicalised. Because this so-called war on terror can only be won, in the long run, through a battle for the minds of the next generation. It certainly won’t be won by the surrender of liberties held dear by democracies and abhorred by the terrorists.

From the Winter 2016 print edition