The Grand Duchy will soon be in the dock again for not applying EU telecom rules on time, although the head of the Luxembourg agency at the centre of the case told Delano that he does not know why the European Commission is pursuing the charges right now.
The commission referred Luxembourg to the European Court of Justice in Kirchberg on Thursday, saying the Grand Duchy’s public utilities and transport regulator, the Institut Luxembourgeois de Régulation, “has failed to carry out a timely analysis of the relevant markets for fixed access to the public telephone network… and for leased lines… in breach of EU telecoms rules.”
The ILR’s last telecoms analysis and rulebook were completed in 2007, and according to European rules it should have finished new ones by last year at the latest.
“The consequence of not carrying out timely analysis of the relevant markets is that regulation may be imposed when it is no longer needed, which would lead to negative consequences for investment incentives, for innovation, and for competition in the market,” the commission said in a press release.
But asked why the case was being pursued this week, Paul Schuh, director of the ILR, said: “I don’t know; it’s a little bit amazing.” On Thursday he told Delano that the consultation for the leased line market will begin in a fortnight, and new rules for fixed telephony subscriptions will be issued next month.
“We know that we are late, but now we are there and we don’t understand why” the commission has decided to file charges this month, since Brussels has been kept apprised of his agency’s plans, he said.
“Strange” timing
In addition, on 9 October the commission published new draft rules that would eliminate most regulation of the two telecom sectors in the EU.
“It is a little bit of a strange attitude from the commission,” said Schuh. “My personal opinion is that it’s a waste of money to go before the court with this case.”
But at the same time, “it’s not dramatic for us” as an agency, he stated.
Whenever the commission finds that EU member states are not correctly applying European directives, then it can take the country to the ECJ. Last year the Grand Duchy had to pay €2 million for not complying with an EU directive on the treatment of urban waste water.
