Under European rules passengers can claim compensation between €250 and €600 for severely delayed or cancelled flights that take off or land in the EU. The policy was affirmed by the European Court of Justice in 2009.
In two new cases currently before the Kirchberg-based court, several airlines are asking for the compensation rules to only be applied when flights are cancelled, not late.
In the first case (C-581/10), Lufthansa is being sued in Cologne district court by a family whose flight from Lagos to Frankfurt arrived 24 hours after its scheduled arrival time.
In the second case (C-629/10), TUI Travel, British Airways, easyJet Airline and the International Air Transport Association are challenging the UK Civil Aviation Authority’s implementation of the three-hour rule in the High Court of Justice of England and Wales.
The British and German judges had asked the ECJ to confirm or revise its 2009 ruling.
However, “the airlines have put forward nothing new which might call into question the interpretation of EU law that the court gave in” 2009, Yves Bot, an advocate general at the ECJ, said in his May 15 opinion.
He rejected the airlines’ arguments that the compensation scheme placed “an arbitrary and unduly severe financial burden on air carriers, particularly since the frequency of delays of more than three hours... appears to be limited.”
Bot added that the EU rules still comply with the international conventions that regulate aviation.
The case now goes to a panel of judges for consideration, a process that could take several months. ECJ judges have no obligation to follow recommendations issued by advocates general, but they agree in the majority of cases.
